import android.R in Eclipse : Why?

Question

An excerpt from the documentation :

Eclipse sometimes likes to add an import android.R statement at the top of your files that use resources, especially when you ask eclipse to sort or otherwise manage imports. This will cause your make to break. Look out for these erroneous import statements and delete them.

My question : WHY? Why does eclipse keep on doing this?

I have been developing Android applications using Eclipse for a quite some time now but I have never been able to understand why eclipse does such a thing.

When I use Ctrl + Shift + O to organize my import statements, import android.R gets added automatically. And all of a sudden my correct code is suddenly covered in red errors, saying that R cannot be resolved. It can get really scary for a beginner as he has no idea what he did wrong.

In another scenario, suppose there is something wrong with my layout files and R.java is not being generated, it says that R cannot be resolved, as R.java has not been generated due to the errors. As I move my cursor to any of the errors, it suggests me to import android.R.

After working on Android for quite sometime now, I know that never to import android.R, but what I have never been able to understand why eclipse keeps on suggesting it, as frankly speaking, adding import android.R never solved any problem of mine. It just added to the existing problems, which used to be really painful during initial days of development.

So, does anyone know the reason behind eclipse making the suggestion to make an incorrect import? Is it just a bug? I don't think it's a bug, as it would have got fixed at least after it was mentioned on the Android documentation.

If it's not a bug, then what is a real purpose of android.R? What does it exactly refer to?

Your opinions/experiences will be really helpful!

Thanks!

Answer 1

Eclipse will also always try to automatically import android.R in your class if you rename your package name via android tools and not rename base package name in your code with the same name because he will assume you have two R's in your file.

Answer 2

Try this...

Window -> Prefs -> Java -> Editor -> Save Actions

Uncheck "Organize Imports." Hopefully that will do it.

After this setting, it works for me.

Answer 3

This is not a bug. There are a few instances where android.R can be helpful and solve problems.

android.R is an R.java file like the one you have in your own projects. The one in your projects (your.packagename.R) holds references to the resources you have under your /res folder like layouts, drawables, XML files, raw files, strings etc.

On the other hand, the android.R file holds references to certain default resources that Android has inbuilt, like simple_list_item_1.

Eclipse suggests this and auto imports this sometimes as if your project's R file hasn't been generated due to an XML error or something, your code will be referencing a file that doesn't exist. By importing android.R, eclipse makes sure your code references a class that exists. However, android.R is unlikely to have the same resources you did, and this will raise another set of errors.