Is there any difference between 'valid xml'

Question

I wasn't aware of a difference, but a coworker says there is, although he can't back it up. What's the difference if any?

Answer 1

In addition to the aforementioned DTD's, there are 2 other ways of describing and validating XML documents are XMLSchema and RelaxNG, both of which may be easier to use and support more features than DTD.

Answer 2

Valid XML is XML that succeeds validation against a DTD.

Well formed XML is XML that has all tags closed in the proper order and, if it has a declaration, it has it first thing in the file with the proper attributes.

In other words, validity refers to semantics, well-formedness refers to syntax.

So you can have invalid well formed XML.

Answer 3

Well, XML that isn't well formed, sort of by definition, isn't XML. Poeple usually refer to valid XML as XML that adheres to a certain schema (XSD or DTD).

Answer 4

If XML is confirming to DTD rules then it's a valid XML. If a XML document is conforming to XML rules (all tags started are closed,there is a root element etc)then it's a well formed XML.

Answer 5

Well-formed vs Valid XML

Well-formed means that a textual object meets the W3C requirements for being XML.

Valid means that well-formed XML meets additional requirements given by a specified schema.

---

Official Definitions

Per the W3C Recommendation for XML:

[Definition: A data object is an XML document if it is well-formed, as defined in this specification. In addition, the XML document is valid if it meets certain further constraints.]

---

Observations:

• A document that is not well-formed is not XML. (Well-formed XML is commonly used but technically redundant.)
• Being valid implies being well-formed.
• Being well-formed does not imply being valid.
• Although the W3C Recommendation for XML defines validity to be against a DTD, conventional use allows the term to be applied for conformance to XML schemas specified via XSD, RELAX NG, Schematron, or other methods.

---

Examples of what causes a document to be...

Not well-formed:

• An element lacks a closing tag (and is not self-closing).
• Elements overlap without proper nesting: <a><b></a></b>
• An attribute value is missing a closing quote that matches the opening quote.
• < or & are used in content rather than &lt or &.
• Multiple root elements exist.
• Multiple XML declarations exist, or an XML declaration appears other than at the top of the document.

Invalid:

• An element or attribute is missing but required by the XML schema.
• An element or attribute is used but undefined by the XML schema.
• The content of an element does not match the content specified by the XML schema.
• The value of an attribute does not match the type specified by the XML schema.

---

Namespace-Well-Formed

Technically, colon characters are permitted in component names in XML. However, colons should only be used in names for namespace purposes:

Note:

The Namespaces in XML Recommendation [XML Names] assigns a meaning to names containing colon characters. Therefore, authors should not use the colon in XML names except for namespace purposes, but XML processors must accept the colon as a name character.

Therefore, another term, namespace-well-formed, is defined in the Namespaces in XML 1.0 W3C Recommendation that implies all of the XML rules for well-formedness plus those governing namespaces and namespace prefixes.

Colloquially, the term well-formed is often used where namespace-well-formed would be more precise. However, this is a minor technical manner of less practical consequence than the distinction between well-formed vs valid XML described in this answer.

Answer 6

DTD is the acronym for Document Type Definition. This is a description of the content for a family of XML files. This is part of the XML 1.0 specification, and allows one to describe and verify that a given document instance conforms to the set of rules detailing its structure and content.

Validation is the process of checking a document against a DTD (more generally against a set of construction rules).

The validation process and building DTDs are the two most difficult parts of the XML life cycle. Briefly a DTD defines all the possible elements to be found within your document, what is the formal shape of your document tree (by defining the allowed content of an element; either text, a regular expression for the allowed list of children, or mixed content i.e. both text and children). The DTD also defines the valid attributes for all elements and the types of those attributes.