How to pickle a python function with its dependenc

Question

As a follow up to this question: Is there an easy way to pickle a python function (or otherwise serialize its code)?

I would like to see an example of this bullet from the above post:

"If the function references globals (including imported modules, other functions etc) that you need to pick up, you'll need to serialise these too, or recreate them on the remote side. My example just gives it the remote process's global namespace."

I have a simple test going where I am writing a functions byte code to a file using marshal:

def g(self,blah): 
    print blah

def f(self):
    for i in range(1,5):
        print 'some function f'
        g('some string used by g')

data = marshal.dumps(f.func_code)

file = open('/tmp/f2.txt', 'w')
file.write(data)

Then starting a fresh python instance I do:

file = open('/tmp/f2.txt', 'r')
code = marshal.loads(file.read())
func2 = types.FunctionType(code, globals(), "some_func_name");
func2('blah')

This results in a:

NameError: global name 'g' is not defined

This is independent of the different approaches I have made to including g. I have tried basically the same approach to sending g over as f but f can still not see g. How do I get g into the global namespace so that it can be used by f in the receiving process?

Someone also recommended looking at pyro as an example of how to do this. I have already made an attempt at trying to understand the related code in the disco project. I took their dPickle class and tried to recreate their disco/tests/test_pickle.py functionality in a standalone app without success. My experiment had problems doing the function marshaling with the dumps call. Anyway, maybe a pyro exploration is next.

In summary, the basic functionality I am after is being able to send a method over the wire and have all the basic "workspace" methods sent over with it (like g).

Example with changes from answer:

Working function_writer:

import marshal, types

def g(blah): 
    print blah


def f():
    for i in range(1,5):
        print 'some function f'
        g('blah string used by g')


f_data = marshal.dumps(f.func_code)
g_data = marshal.dumps(g.func_code);

f_file = open('/tmp/f.txt', 'w')
f_file.write(f_data)

g_file = open('/tmp/g.txt', 'w')
g_file.write(g_data)

Working function_reader:

import marshal, types

f_file = open('/tmp/f.txt', 'r')
g_file = open('/tmp/g.txt', 'r')

f_code = marshal.loads(f_file.read())
g_code = marshal.loads(g_file.read())

f = types.FunctionType(f_code, globals(), 'f');
g = types.FunctionType(g_code, globals(), 'g');

f()

Answer 1

The cloud package does this -- just 'pip install cloud' and then:

import cloud, pickle
def foo(x): 
    return x*3
def bar(z): 
    return foo(z)+1
x = cloud.serialization.cloudpickle.dumps(bar)
del foo 
del bar
f = pickle.loads(x)
print f(3)  # displays "10"

In other words, just call cloudpickle.dump() or cloudpickle.dumps() the same way you'd use pickle.*, then later use the native pickle.load() or pickle.loads() to thaw.

Picloud released the 'cloud' python package under the LGPL, and other open-source projects are already using it (google for "cloudpickle.py" to see a few). The documentation at picloud.com gives you an idea how powerful this code is, and why they had an incentive to put the effort into making general-purpose code pickling work -- their whole business is built around it. The idea is that if you have cpu_intensive_function() and want to run it on Amazon's EC2 grid, you just replace:

cpu_intensive_function(some, args) 

with:

cloud.call(cpu_intensive_function, some, args)

The latter uses cloudpickle to pickle up any dependent code and data, ships it to EC2, runs it, and returns the results to you when you call cloud.result(). (Picloud bills in millisecond increments, it's cheap as heck, and I use it all the time for monte carlo simulations and financial time series analysis, when I need hundreds of CPU cores for just a few seconds each. I can't say enough good things about it and I don't even work there.)

Answer 2

I have tried basically the same approach to sending g over as f but f can still not see g. How do I get g into the global namespace so that it can be used by f in the receiving process?

Assign it to the global name g. (I see you are assigning f to func2 rather than to f. If you are doing something like that with g, then it is clear why f can't find g. Remember that name resolution happens at runtime -- g isn't looked up until you call f.)

Of course, I'm guessing since you didn't show the code you're using to do this.

It might be best to create a separate dictionary to use for the global namespace for the functions you're unpickling -- a sandbox. That way all their global variables will be separate from the module you're doing this in. So you might do something like this:

sandbox = {}

with open("functions.pickle", "rb") as funcfile:
    while True:
        try:
            code = marshal.load(funcfile)
        except EOFError:
             break
        sandbox[code.co_name] = types.FunctionType(code, sandbox, code.co_name)

In this example I assume that you've put the code objects from all your functions in one file, one after the other, and when reading them in, I get the code object's name and use it as the basis for both the function object's name and the name under which it's stored in the sandbox dictionary.

Inside the unpickled functions, the sandbox dictionary is their globals() and so inside f(), g gets its value from sandbox["g"]. To call f then would be: sandbox["f"]("blah")

Answer 3

Every module has its own globals, there are no universal globals. We can "implant" restored functions into some module and use this like a normal module.

-- save --

import marshal
def f(x):
    return x + 1
def g(x):
    return f(x) ** 2
funcfile = open("functions.pickle", "wb")
marshal.dump(f.func_code, funcfile)
marshal.dump(g.func_code, funcfile)
funcfile.close()

-- restore --

import marshal
import types
open('sandbox.py', 'w').write('')  # create an empty module 'sandbox'
import sandbox
with open("functions.pickle", "rb") as funcfile:
    while True:
        try:
            code = marshal.load(funcfile)
        except EOFError:
             break
        func = types.FunctionType(code, sandbox.__dict__, code.co_name)
        setattr(sandbox, code.co_name, func)   # or sandbox.f = ... if the name is fixed
assert sandbox.g(3) == 16   # f(3) ** 2
# it is possible import them from other modules
from sandbox import g

---

Edited:
You can do also import some module .e.g. "sys" to "sandbox" namespace from outside:

sandbox.sys = __import__('sys')

or the same:

exec 'import sys' in sandbox.__dict__
assert 'sys' in sandbox, 'Verify imported into sandbox'

Your original code would work if you do it not in ipython interactive but in a python program or normal python interactive!!!

Ipython uses some strange namespace that is not a dict of any module from sys.modules. Normal python or any main program use sys.modules['__main__'].__dict__ as globals(). Any module uses that_module.__dict__ which is also OK, only ipython interactive is a problem.

Answer 4

Dill (along with other pickle variants, cloudpickle, etc.) seem to work when the function(s) being pickled are in the main module along with the pickling. If you are pickling a function from another module, that module name has to be present when the unpickling happens. I cannot seem to find a way around this limitation.

Answer 5

You can get a better handle on global objects by importing __main__, and using the methods available in that module. This is what dill does in order to serialize almost anything in python. Basically, when dill serializes an interactively defined function, it uses some name mangling on __main__ on both the serialization and deserialization side that makes __main__ a valid module.

>>> import dill
>>> 
>>> def bar(x):
...   return foo(x) + x
... 
>>> def foo(x):
...   return x**2
... 
>>> bar(3)
12
>>> 
>>> _bar = dill.loads(dill.dumps(bar))
>>> _bar(3)
12

Actually, dill registers it's types into the pickle registry, so if you have some black box code that uses pickle and you can't really edit it, then just importing dill can magically make it work without monkeypatching the 3rd party code.

Or, if you want the whole interpreter session sent over as an "python image", dill can do that too.

>>> # continuing from above
>>> dill.dump_session('foobar.pkl')
>>>
>>> ^D
dude@sakurai>$ python
Python 2.7.5 (default, Sep 30 2013, 20:15:49) 
[GCC 4.2.1 (Apple Inc. build 5566)] on darwin
Type "help", "copyright", "credits" or "license" for more information.
>>> import dill
>>> dill.load_session('foobar.pkl')
>>> _bar(3)
12

You can easily send the image across ssh to another computer, and start where you left off there as long as there's version compatibility of pickle and the usual caveats about python changing and things being installed.