multi-user application record locking - best metho

Question

I'm developing a php / mysql application that handles multiple simultaneous users. I'm thinking of the best approach to take when it comes to locking / warning against records that are currently being viewed / edited.

The scenario to avoid is two users viewing the record, one making a change, then the other doing likewise - with the potential that one change might overwrite the previous.

In the latest versions of WordPress they use some method to detect this, but it does not seem wholly reliable - often returning false positives, at least in my experience.

I assume some form of ajax must be in place to 'ping' the application and let it know the record is still being viewed / edited (otherwise, a user might simply close their browser window, and then how would the application know that).

Another solution I could see is to check the last updated time when a record is submitted for update, to see if in the interim it has been updated elsewhere - and then offer the user a choice to proceed or discard their own changes.

Perhaps I'm barking up the wrong tree in terms of a solution - what are peoples experiences of implementing this (what must be a fairly common) requirement?

Answer 1

Good idea with the timestamp comparison. It's inexpensive to implement, and it's an inexpensive operation to run in production. You just have to write the logic to send back to the user the status message that their write/update didn't occur because someone beat them to it.

Perhaps consider storing the username on each update in a field called something like 'LastUpdateBy', and return that back to the user who had their update pre-empted. Just a little nicety for the user. Nice in the corporate sense, perhaps not in an environment where it might not be appropriate.

Answer 2

I would do this: Store the time of the last modification in the edit form. Compare this time on submission with the time stored in the database. If they are the same, lock the table, update the data (along with the modification time) and unlock the table. If the times are different, notify the user about it and ask for the next step.

Answer 3

see: What can I do to prevent write-write conflicts on a wiki-style website?