Canonical links and 301 Redirect if URL doesn'

Question

I am trying to implement a URL scheme similar to stack overflow's in django/python.

E.g. the pk is stored in the URL along with a slug of the title so for this question (id #4787731) the URL is

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4787731/canonical-links-and-301-redirect-if-url-doesnt-match-slug

If I later change the title (or just put in some random crud into the url) then the site will still know which question I am after (by the ID) and will 301 redirect to the correct URL - e.g. try.

https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4787731/canonical-links-MODIFIED-URL

So

• What is the best way to include canonical links in my pages such as

  <link rel="canonical" href="https://stackoverflow.com/questions/4787731/canonical-links-and-301-redirect-if-url-doesnt-match-slug">

(can I use get_absolute_url)

• What is the best way to recognize that the current URL doesn't match the canonical link and issue a 301?

Note - This question is similar but only addresses the case of generating the slug on the fly or statically.

Answer 1

1: I don't think there's a point in using the canonical tag if there are 301s anyways.

Let's just imagine a scenario where you change the URL from /q/111/hello-world to /q/111/foobar. The engines won't assume the two are equal unless they visit the original url with the canonical tag on it pointing to /q/111/foobar (which it wont, because it's now a 301, severing any proof of a relationship between the pages).

2: I'd do it the straight forward way. Define a non unique slug field and compare vs the captured URL in your detail view.

# models
class MyModel(models.Model):
    # ...
    non_unique_slug = models.SlugField()

    def get_absolute_url(self):
        return "/questions/%s/%s" % (self.id, self.non_unique_slug)


# urls
    r'^questions/(?P<id>\d+)/(?P<slug>[\w-]+)/$' 

# views
def my_view(request, id, slug):
    page = Page.objects.get(id=id)
    if not slug == page.slug:
        return http.HttpResponsePermanentRedirect(page.get_absolute_url())

    # render page
    return direct_to_template(request, "foobar.html", {'page': page})

Answer 2

I followed Yuji's helpful instructions but found that you'll need to use the HttpResponsePermanentRedirect object to get a permanent 301 instead of the temporary 302.

• https://docs.djangoproject.com/en/dev/ref/request-response/#django.http.HttpResponsePermanentRedirect