ZooKeeper alternatives? (cluster coordination serv

Question

ZooKeeper is a highly available coordination service for data centers. It originated in the Hadoop project. One can implement locking, fail over, leader election, group membership and other coordination issues on top of it. Are there any alternatives to ZooKeeper? (free software of course)

Answer 1

I'd found this comparison of Zookeeper, etcd and Doozer: http://devo.ps/blog/zookeeper-vs-doozer-vs-etcd/

Serf (serfdom.io) is also a nice solution as it is simple! But you must consider, SERF is just a cluster-manager which enables you to send custom events to all cluster nodes. Thats nice, but you have to write your own shell scripts (aka events). See this example: "https://www.digitalocean.com/community/articles/how-to-set-up-a-serf-cluster-on-several-ubuntu-vps"

The advantage is, you're getting a very simple cluster-manager and you're able to combine this with your favorite configuration, deployment or continuous integration tool.

Answer 2

There's a very promising alternative to ZooKeeper called etcd (github.com/coreos/etcd), written by CoreOS team. Unlike Doozerd, etcd is being actively developed.

Answer 3

I've looked extensively at Zookeeper/Curator, Eureka, etcd, and consul. Zookeeper/Curator and Eureka are in many ways the most polished and easiest to integrate if you are in the Java world. Etcd is pretty cool and very flexible, but It is really just a HA key store so you would have to write a lot of code to turn it into an opinionated service discovery system.

Consul is (to me) the best of both worlds. It is an opinionated service discovery system written on top of serf, using raft for cluster consensus and gossip for communication. It exposes the discovery / registration endpoints with a well documented REST api, and also allows you to discover services with DNS SRV records, and register services with configuration (i.e. so you can register a database or application you can't integrate a client with, or if you just want to keep your service discovery decoupled from your app)

I've written a blog post about consul where you can learn more and walk through my "try it out" demo

I've also discussed service discovery with etcd & docker if you want to see more about what that custom code might look like.

One last thing! etcd & consul are written in go, so maintaining them is much easier then java solutions like zookeeper. All you need is the consul / etcd binary. no dependencies, no linked libraries, no jvm.

Answer 4

Take a look at Serf. There is a comparison vs Zookeeper here.

Answer 5

There are different tools that optimize for different engineering trade-offs.

• ZooKeeper Scales marginally for reads; writes with many observers can be slow. It is proven and has a sizable community.
• Accord Seems interesting for write-intensive uses, however typical use-cases already have domain-specific solutions (i.e., logging, telemetry).

The others are somewhat interesting but generally unproven. Don't get this wrong if intended for production usage.

Answer 6

I know this post is quite old, but someone who is looking at all possible alternatives I would also like to suggest JGroups library which is mature enough to be used in production environment. I have used it successfully in one of my projects mainly for distributed coordination and to share messages between cluster. It also support AWS support in addition to its flexible architecture where you can customize its stack to get what you need. I suggest you to have a look at it