Best implementation for hashCode method for a coll

Question

How do we decide on the best implementation of hashCode() method for a collection (assuming that equals method has been overridden correctly) ?

Answer 1

First make sure that equals is implemented correctly. From an IBM DeveloperWorks article:

• Symmetry: For two references, a and b, a.equals(b) if and only if b.equals(a)
• Reflexivity: For all non-null references, a.equals(a)
• Transitivity: If a.equals(b) and b.equals(c), then a.equals(c)

Then make sure that their relation with hashCode respects the contact (from the same article):

• Consistency with hashCode(): Two equal objects must have the same hashCode() value

Finally a good hash function should strive to approach the ideal hash function.

Answer 2

There's a good implementation of the Effective Java's hashcode() and equals() logic in Apache Commons Lang. Checkout HashCodeBuilder and EqualsBuilder.

Answer 3

about8.blogspot.com, you said

if equals() returns true for two objects, then hashCode() should return the same value. If equals() returns false, then hashCode() should return different values

I cannot agree with you. If two objects have the same hashcode it doesn't have to mean that they are equal.

If A equals B then A.hashcode must be equal to B.hascode

but

if A.hashcode equals B.hascode it does not mean that A must equals B

Answer 4

If you're happy with the Effective Java implementation recommended by dmeister, you can use a library call instead of rolling your own:

@Override
public int hashCode() {
    return Objects.hashCode(this.firstName, this.lastName);
}

This requires either Guava (com.google.common.base.Objects.hashCode) or the standard library in Java 7 (java.util.Objects.hash) but works the same way.

Answer 5

@about8 : there is a pretty serious bug there.

Zam obj1 = new Zam("foo", "bar", "baz");
Zam obj2 = new Zam("fo", "obar", "baz");

same hashcode

you probably want something like

public int hashCode() {
    return (getFoo().hashCode() + getBar().hashCode()).toString().hashCode();

(can you get hashCode directly from int in Java these days? I think it does some autocasting.. if that's the case, skip the toString, it's ugly.)

Answer 6

If you use eclipse, you can generate equals() and hashCode() using:

Source -> Generate hashCode() and equals().

Using this function you can decide which fields you want to use for equality and hash code calculation, and Eclipse generates the corresponding methods.