How do I put an already-running process under nohu

Question

I have a process that is already running for a long time and don't want to end it.

How do I put it under nohup (that is, how do I cause it to continue running even if I close the terminal?)

Answer 1

Unrfortunately disown is specific to bash and not available in all shells.

Certain flavours of Unix (e.g. AIX and Solaris) have an option on the nohup command itself which can be applied to a running process:

nohup -p pid

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nohup

Answer 2

Node's answer is really great, but it left open the question how can get stdout and stderr redirected. I found a solution on Unix & Linux, but it is also not complete. I would like to merge these two solutions. Here it is:

For my test I made a small bash script called loop.sh, which prints the pid of itself with a minute sleep in an infinite loop.

$./loop.sh

Now get the PID of this process somehow. Usually ps -C loop.sh is good enough, but it is printed in my case.

Now we can switch to another terminal (or press ^Z and in the same terminal). Now gdb should be attached to this process.

$ gdb -p <PID>

This stops the script (if running). Its state can be checked by ps -f <PID>, where the STAT field is 'T+' (or in case of ^Z 'T'), which means (man ps(1))

    T Stopped, either by a job control signal or because it is being traced
    + is in the foreground process group

(gdb) call close(1)
$1 = 0

Close(1) returns zero on success.

(gdb) call open("loop.out", 01102, 0600)
$6 = 1

Open(1) returns the new file descriptor if successful.

This open is equal with open(path, O_TRUNC|O_CREAT|O_RDWR, S_IRUSR|S_IWUSR). Instead of O_RDWR O_WRONLY could be applied, but /usr/sbin/lsof says 'u' for all std* file handlers (FD column), which is O_RDWR.

I checked the values in /usr/include/bits/fcntl.h header file.

The output file could be opened with O_APPEND, as nohup would do, but this is not suggested by man open(2), because of possible NFS problems.

If we get -1 as a return value, then call perror("") prints the error message. If we need the errno, use p errno gdb comand.

Now we can check the newly redirected file. /usr/sbin/lsof -p <PID> prints:

loop.sh <PID> truey    1u   REG   0,26        0 15008411 /home/truey/loop.out

If we want, we can redirect stderr to another file, if we want to using call close(2) and call open(...) again using a different file name.

Now the attached bash has to be released and we can quit gdb:

(gdb) detach
Detaching from program: /bin/bash, process <PID>
(gdb) q

If the script was stopped by gdb from an other terminal it continues to run. We can switch back to loop.sh's terminal. Now it does not write anything to the screen, but running and writing into the file. We have to put it into the background. So press ^Z.

^Z
[1]+  Stopped                 ./loop.sh

(Now we are in the same state as if ^Z was pressed at the beginning.)

Now we can check the state of the job:

$ ps -f 24522
UID        PID  PPID  C STIME TTY      STAT   TIME CMD
<UID>    <PID><PPID>  0 11:16 pts/36   S      0:00 /bin/bash ./loop.sh
$ jobs
[1]+  Stopped                 ./loop.sh

So process should be running in the background and detached from the terminal. The number in the jobs command's output in square brackets identifies the job inside bash. We can use in the following built in bash commands applying a '%' sign before the job number :

$ bg %1
[1]+ ./loop.sh &
$ disown -h %1
$ ps -f <PID>
UID        PID  PPID  C STIME TTY      STAT   TIME CMD
<UID>    <PID><PPID>  0 11:16 pts/36   S      0:00 /bin/bash ./loop.sh

And now we can quit from the calling bash. The process continues running in the background. If we quit its PPID become 1 (init(1) process) and the control terminal become unknown.

$ ps -f <PID>
UID        PID  PPID  C STIME TTY      STAT   TIME CMD
<UID>    <PID>     1  0 11:16 ?        S      0:00 /bin/bash ./loop.sh
$ /usr/bin/lsof -p <PID>
...
loop.sh <PID> truey    0u   CHR 136,36                38 /dev/pts/36 (deleted)
loop.sh <PID> truey    1u   REG   0,26     1127 15008411 /home/truey/loop.out
loop.sh <PID> truey    2u   CHR 136,36                38 /dev/pts/36 (deleted)

COMMENT

The gdb stuff can be automatized creating a file (e.g. loop.gdb) containing the commands and run gdb -q -x loop.gdb -p <PID>. My loop.gdb looks like this:

call close(1)
call open("loop.out", 01102, 0600)
# call close(2)
# call open("loop.err", 01102, 0600)
detach
quit

Or one can use the following one liner instead:

gdb -q -ex 'call close(1)' -ex 'call open("loop.out", 01102, 0600)' -ex detach -ex quit -p <PID>

I hope this is a fairly complete description of the solution.

Answer 3

1. ctrl + z - this will pause the job (not going to cancel!)
2. bg - this will put the job in background and return in running process
3. disown -a - this will cut all the attachment with job (so you can close the terminal and it will still run)

These simple steps will allow you to close the terminal while keeping process running.

It wont put on nohup (based on my understanding of your question, you don't need it here).

Answer 4

To send running process to nohup (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nohup)

nohup -p pid , it did not worked for me

Then I tried the following commands and it worked very fine

1. Run some SOMECOMMAND, say /usr/bin/python /vol/scripts/python_scripts/retention_all_properties.py 1.

2. Ctrl+Z to stop (pause) the program and get back to the shell.

3. bg to run it in the background.

4. disown -h so that the process isn't killed when the terminal closes.

5. Type exit to get out of the shell because now you're good to go as the operation will run in the background in its own process, so it's not tied to a shell.

This process is the equivalent of running nohup SOMECOMMAND.

Answer 5

The command to separate a running job from the shell ( = makes it nohup) is disown and a basic shell-command.

From bash-manpage (man bash):

disown [-ar] [-h] [jobspec ...]

Without options, each jobspec is removed from the table of active jobs. If the -h option is given, each jobspec is not removed from the table, but is marked so that SIGHUP is not sent to the job if the shell receives a SIGHUP. If no jobspec is present, and neither the -a nor the -r option is supplied, the current job is used. If no jobspec is supplied, the -a option means to remove or mark all jobs; the -r option without a jobspec argument restricts operation to running jobs. The return value is 0 unless a jobspec does not specify a valid job.

That means, that a simple

disown -a

will remove all jobs from the job-table and makes them nohup

Answer 6

On my AIX system, I tried

nohup -p  processid>

This worked well. It continued to run my process even after closing terminal windows. We have ksh as default shell so the bg and disown commands didn't work.