Reading 64bit Registry from a 32bit application

Question

I have a c# unit test project that is compiled for AnyCPU. Our build server is a 64bit machine, and has a 64bit SQL Express instance installed.

The test project uses code similar to the following to identify the path to the .MDF files:

    private string GetExpressPath()
    {
        RegistryKey sqlServerKey = Registry.LocalMachine.OpenSubKey( @"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server\Instance Names\SQL" );
        string sqlExpressKeyName = (string) sqlServerKey.GetValue( "SQLEXPRESS" );
        RegistryKey sqlInstanceSetupKey = sqlServerKey.OpenSubKey( sqlExpressKeyName + @"\Setup" );
        return sqlInstanceSetupKey.GetValue( "SQLDataRoot" ).ToString();
    }

This code works fine on our 32bit workstations, and did work ok on the build server until I recently enabled code coverage analysis with NCover. Because NCover uses a 32bit COM component, the test runner (Gallio) runs as a 32bit process.

Checking the registry, there is no "Instance Names" key under

HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\SOFTWARE\Wow6432Node\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server

Is there a way for an application running in 32bit mode to access the registry outside Wow6432Node?

Answer 1

There is still native support for registry access under 64 bit Windows using .NET Framework 4.x. The following code is tested with  Windows 7, 64 bit  and also with  Windows 10, 64 bit. To access the 64 bit registry, you can use:

string value64 = string.Empty; 
RegistryKey localKey = 
    RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(Microsoft.Win32.RegistryHive.LocalMachine, 
        RegistryView.Registry64); 
localKey = localKey.OpenSubKey(@"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows NT\CurrentVersion"); 
if (localKey != null) 
{ 
    value64 = localKey.GetValue("RegisteredOrganization").ToString(); 
    localKey.Close();
} 
Console.WriteLine(String.Format("RegisteredOrganization [value64]: {0}",value64));

If you want to access the 32bit registry, use:

string value32 = string.Empty; 
RegistryKey localKey32 = 
    RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(Microsoft.Win32.RegistryHive.LocalMachine, 
        RegistryView.Registry32); 
localKey32 = localKey32.OpenSubKey(@"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows NT\CurrentVersion"); 
if (localKey32 != null) 
{ 
    value32 = localKey32.GetValue("RegisteredOrganization").ToString(); 
    localKey32.Close();
} 
Console.WriteLine(String.Format("RegisteredOrganization [value32]: {0}",value32));

Don't be confused, both versions are using Microsoft.Win32.RegistryHive.LocalMachine as first parameter, you make the distinction whether to use 64 bit or 32 bit by the 2nd parameter (RegistryView.Registry64 versus RegistryView.Registry32).

Note that

• On a 64bit Windows, HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\Software\Wow6432Node contains values used by 32 bit applications running on the 64 bit system. Only true 64 bit applications store their values in HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\Software directly. The subtree Wow6432Node is entirely transparent for 32 bit applications, 32 bit applications still see HKEY_LOCAL_MACHINE\Software as they expect it (it is a kind of redirection). In older versions of Windows as well as 32 bit Windows 7 (and Vista 32 bit) the subtree Wow6432Node obviously does not exist.

• Due to a bug in Windows 7 (64 bit), the 32 bit source code version always returns "Microsoft" regardless which organization you have registered while the 64 bit source code version returns the right organization.

Coming back to the example you've provided, do it the following way to access the 64 bit branch:

RegistryKey localKey = 
    RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(Microsoft.Win32.RegistryHive.LocalMachine, 
        RegistryView.Registry64); 
RegistryKey sqlServerKey = localKey.OpenSubKey(
    @"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server\Instance Names\SQL");
string sqlExpressKeyName = (string) sqlServerKey.GetValue("SQLEXPRESS");

---

Additional information for practical use:

I'd like to add an interesting approach Johny Skovdal has suggested in the comments, which I've picked up to develop some useful functions by using his approach: In some situations you want to get back all keys regardless whether it is 32 bit or 64 bit. The SQL instance names are such an example. You can use a union query in that case as follows (C#6 or higher):

// using Microsoft.Win32;
public static IEnumerable<string> GetRegValueNames(RegistryView view, string regPath,
                                  RegistryHive hive = RegistryHive.LocalMachine) 
{ 
    return RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(hive, view)
                     ?.OpenSubKey(regPath)?.G‌​etValueNames();
}

public static IEnumerable<string> GetAllRegValueNames(string RegPath,
                                  RegistryHive hive = RegistryHive.LocalMachine) 
{
    var reg64 = GetRegValueNames(RegistryView.Registry64, RegPath, hive);
    var reg32 = GetRegValueNames(RegistryView.Re‌​gistry32, RegPath, hive);
    var result = (reg64 != null && reg32 != null) ? reg64.Union(reg32) : (reg64 ?? reg32);
    return (result ?? new List<string>().AsEnumerable()).OrderBy(x => x);
}

public static object GetRegValue(RegistryView view, string regPath, string ValueName="",
                                 RegistryHive hive = RegistryHive.LocalMachine)
{
    return RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(hive, view)
                       ?.OpenSubKey(regPath)?.G‌​etValue(ValueName);
}

public static object GetRegValue(string RegPath, string ValueName="",
                                 RegistryHive hive = RegistryHive.LocalMachine)
{   
    return GetRegValue(RegistryView.Registry64, RegPath, ValueName, hive) 
                     ?? GetRegValue(RegistryView.Re‌​gistry32, RegPath, ValueName, hive);
}

public static IEnumerable<string> GetRegKeyNames(RegistryView view, string regPath,
                   RegistryHive hive = RegistryHive.LocalMachine)
{
    return RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(hive, view)
        ?.OpenSubKey(regPath)?.GetSubKeyNames(); 
}

public static IEnumerable<string> GetAllRegKeyNames(string RegPath,
                                  RegistryHive hive = RegistryHive.LocalMachine)
{
    var reg64 = GetRegKeyNames(RegistryView.Registry64, RegPath, hive);
    var reg32 = GetRegKeyNames(RegistryView.Re‌​gistry32, RegPath, hive);
    var result = (reg64 != null && reg32 != null) ? reg64.Union(reg32) : (reg64 ?? reg32);
    return (result ?? new List<string>().AsEnumerable()).OrderBy(x => x);
}

Now you can simply use the functions above as follows:

var sqlRegPath=@"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server\Instance Names\SQL";
foreach (var valueName in GetAllRegValueNames(sqlRegPath))
{
    var value=GetRegValue(sqlRegPath, valueName);
    Console.WriteLine($"{valueName}={value}");
}

which will give you a list of the value names and values in sqlRegPath.

Note: You can access the default value of a key (displayed by the commandline tool REGEDT32.EXE as (Default)) if you omit the ValueName parameter in the corresponding functions above.

To get a list of SubKeys within a registry key, use the function GetRegKeyNamesor GetAllRegKeyNames. You can use this list to traverse further keys in the registry.

For example

var currentVersionRegPath = @"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Windows\CurrentVersion";
var uninstallRegPath = $@"{currentVersionRegPath}\Uninstall";
var regKeys = Registry.GetAllRegKeyNames(RegPath: uninstallRegPath);

will get all 32 bit and 64 bit uninstall keys.

Notice the null handling required in the functions because SQL server can be installed as 32 bit or as 64 bit. The functions are overloaded so you can still pass the 32 bit or 64 bit parameter if required - however, if you omit it then it will try to read 64 bit, if that fails (null value), it reads the 32 bit values.

There is one speciality here: Because GetAllRegValueNames is usually used in a loop context (see example above), it returns an empty enumerable rather than null to simplify foreach loops: if it wouldn't be handled that way, the loop would have to be prefixed by an if statement checking for null which would be cumbersome having to do that - so that is dealt with once in the function.

Why bothering about null? Because if you don't care, you'll have a lot more headaches finding out why that null reference exception was thrown in your code - you'd spend a lot of time finding out where and why it happened. And if it happened in production you'll be very busy studying log files or event logs (I hope you have logging implemented) ... better avoid null issues where you can in a defensive way. The operators ?., ?[...] and ?? can help you a lot (see the code provided above). There is a nice related article discussing the new nullable reference types in C#, which I recommend to read and also this one about the Elvis operator.

---

Hint: You can use the free edition of Linqpad to test all examples under Windows. It doesn't require an installation. Don't forget to press F4 and enter Microsoft.Win32 in the Namespace import tab. In Visual Studio, you require using Microsoft.Win32; at the top of your code.

Tip: To familiarize yourself with the new null handling operators, try out (and debug) the following code in LinqPad:

string[] test { get { return null;} } // property used to return null
void Main()
{
    test.Dump();                    // output: null
    // "elvis" operator:
    test?.Dump();                   // output: 
    // "elvis" operator for arrays
    test?[0].Dump();                // output: 
    (test?[0]).Dump();              // output: null
    // combined with null coalescing operator (brackets required):
    (test?[0]??"<null>").Dump();    // output: "<null>"
}

If you're interested, here are some examples I put together showing what else you can do with the tool.

Answer 2

I don't have enough rep to comment, but it's worth pointing out that it works when opening a remote registry using OpenRemoteBaseKey. Adding the RegistryView.Registry64 parameter allows a 32-bit program on Machine A to access the 64-bit registry on Machine B. Before I passed that parameter, my program was reading the 32-bit after OpenRemoteBaseKey, and did not find the key I was after.

Note: In my test, the remote machine was actually my machine, but I accessed it via OpenRemoteBaseKey, just as I would for a different machine.

Answer 3

If you cannot use .NET 4 with its RegistryKey.OpenBaseKey(..., RegistryView.Registry64), you need to use Windows API directly.

The minimal interop is like:

internal enum RegistryFlags
{
    ...
    RegSz = 0x02,
    ...
    SubKeyWow6464Key = 0x00010000,
    ...
}

internal enum RegistryType
{
    RegNone = 0,
    ...
}

[DllImport("advapi32", CharSet = CharSet.Unicode, SetLastError = true)]
public static extern int RegGetValue(
    UIntPtr hkey, string lpSubKey, string lpValue, RegistryFlags dwFlags, 
    out RegistryType pdwType, IntPtr pvData, ref uint pcbData);

Use it like:

IntPtr data = IntPtr.Zero;
RegistryType type;
uint len = 0;
RegistryFlags flags = RegistryFlags.RegSz | RegistryFlags.SubKeyWow6464Key;
UIntPtr key = (UIntPtr)((uint)RegistryHive.LocalMachine);

const string subkey= @"SOFTWARE\Microsoft\Microsoft SQL Server\Instance Names\SQL";
const string value = "SQLEXPRESS";

if (RegGetValue(key, subkey, value, flags, out type, data, ref len) == 0)
{
    data = Marshal.AllocHGlobal((int)len);
    if (RegGetValue(key, subkey, value, flags, out type, data, ref len) == 0)
    {
        string sqlExpressKeyName = Marshal.PtrToStringUni(data);
    }
}

Answer 4

you have to use the KEY_WOW64_64KEY param when creating/opening the registry key. But AFAIK that's not possible with the Registry class but only when using the API directly.

This might help to get you started.

Answer 5

try this (from a 32bit process):

> %WINDIR%\sysnative\reg.exe query ...

(found that here).