Check if a program exists from a Makefile

2019-01-21 18:05发布

How can I check if a program is callable from a Makefile?

(That is, the program should exist in the path or otherwise be callable.)

It could be used to check for which compiler is installed, for instance.

E.g. something like this question, but without assuming the underlying shell is POSIX compatible.

10条回答
贼婆χ
2楼-- · 2019-01-21 18:53

Sometimes you need a Makefile to be able to run on different target OS's and you want the build to fail early if a required executable is not in PATH rather than to run for a possibly long time before failing.

The excellent solution provided by engineerchuan requires making a target. However, if you have many executables to test and your Makefile has many independent targets, each of which requires the tests, then each target requires the test target as a dependency. That makes for a lot of extra typing as well as processing time when you make more than one target at a time.

The solution provided by 0xf can test for an executable without making a target. That saves a lot of typing and execution time when there are multiple targets that can be built either separately or together.

My improvement to the latter solution is to use the which executable (where in Windows), rather than to rely on there being a --version option in each executable, directly in the GNU Make ifeq directive, rather than to define a new variable, and to use the GNU Make error function to stop the build if a required executable is not in ${PATH}. For example, to test for the lzop executable:

 ifeq (, $(shell which lzop))
 $(error "No lzop in $(PATH), consider doing apt-get install lzop")
 endif

If you have several executables to check, then you might want to use a foreach function with the which executable:

EXECUTABLES = ls dd dudu lxop
K := $(foreach exec,$(EXECUTABLES),\
        $(if $(shell which $(exec)),some string,$(error "No $(exec) in PATH")))

Note the use of the := assignment operator that is required in order to force immediate evaluation of the RHS expression. If your Makefile changes the PATH, then instead of the last line above you will need:

        $(if $(shell PATH=$(PATH) which $(exec)),some string,$(error "No $(exec) in PATH")))

This should give you output similar to:

ads$ make
Makefile:5: *** "No dudu in PATH.  Stop.
查看更多
smile是对你的礼貌
3楼-- · 2019-01-21 18:59

For me all above answers are based on linux and are not working with windows. I'm new to make so my approach may not be ideal. But complete example that works for me on both linux and windows is this:

# detect what shell is used
ifeq ($(findstring cmd.exe,$(SHELL)),cmd.exe)
$(info "shell Windows cmd.exe")
DEVNUL := NUL
WHICH := where
else
$(info "shell Bash")
DEVNUL := /dev/null
WHICH := which
endif

# detect platform independently if gcc is installed
ifeq ($(shell ${WHICH} gcc 2>${DEVNUL}),)
$(error "gcc is not in your system PATH")
else
$(info "gcc found")
endif

optionally when I need to detect more tools I can use:

EXECUTABLES = ls dd 
K := $(foreach myTestCommand,$(EXECUTABLES),\
        $(if $(shell ${WHICH} $(myTestCommand) 2>${DEVNUL} ),\
            $(myTestCommand) found,\
            $(error "No $(myTestCommand) in PATH)))
$(info ${K})        
查看更多
不美不萌又怎样
4楼-- · 2019-01-21 19:01

Solved by compiling a special little program in another makefile target, whose sole purpose is to check for whatever runtime stuff I was looking for.

Then, I called this program in yet another makefile target.

It was something like this if I recall correctly:

real: checker real.c
    cc -o real real.c `./checker`

checker: checker.c
    cc -o checker checker.c
查看更多
乱世女痞
5楼-- · 2019-01-21 19:02

I mixed the solutions from @kenorb and @0xF and got this:

DOT := $(shell command -v dot 2> /dev/null)

all:
ifndef DOT
    $(error "dot is not available please install graphviz")
endif
    dot -Tpdf -o pres.pdf pres.dot 

It works beautifully because "command -v" doesn't print anything if the executable is not available, so the variable DOT never gets defined and you can just check it whenever you want in your code. In this example I'm throwing an error, but you could do something more useful if you wanted.

If the variable is available, "command -v" performs the inexpensive operation of printing the command path, defining the DOT variable.

查看更多
登录 后发表回答