Add event handler to React.DOM element dynamically

Question

I'm working with a RadioButtonGroup component which is like radio input but with buttons:

It would be good if using the component was easy like this:

var SelectThing = React.createClass({
    render: function render() {
        // I would not like to add onClick handler to every button element
        // outside the RadioButtonGroup component
        return (
            <RadioButtonGroup onChange={this._onActiveChange}>
                <button>Thing 1</button>
                <button>Thing 2</button>
                <button>Thing 3</button>
            </RadioButtonGroup>
        )
    },

    _onActiveChange: function _onActiveChange(index) {
        console.log('You clicked button with index:', index);
    }
});

The actual question: How can I achieve that the most elegantly with React? (I found another similar question but it doesn't exactly answer to this).

My first intuition was to add and remove the onClick handlers inside the component to remove boiler plate code from the component's user. Another option that comes to my mind is to give e.g. <p> elements instead of button elements and put them inside button elements which would be created inside the RadioButtonGroup component. I don't like the latter that much because it doesn't make that much sense semantically compared to passing buttons.

Here's what the (obviously not working) component looks like now:

// Radio input with buttons
// http://getbootstrap.com/javascript/#buttons-checkbox-radio
var RadioButtonGroup = React.createClass({
    getInitialState: function getInitialState() {
        return {
            active: this.props.active || 0
        };
    },

    componentWillMount: function componentWillMount() {
        var buttons = this.props.children;
        buttons[this.props.active].className += ' active';

        var self = this;
        buttons.forEach(function(button, index) {
            // How to dynamically set onclick handler for virtual dom
            // element created inside JSX?
            button.addEventListener('onClick', function(event) {
                self._onAnyButtonClick(index, event);
            }
        });
    },

    componentWillUnmount: function componentWillUnmount() {
        var buttons = this.props.children;

        buttons.forEach(function(button, index) {
            button.removeEventListener('onClick');
        });  
    },

    render: function render() {
        return (
            <div className="radio-button-group">
                {buttons}
            </div>
        )
    },

    _onAnyButtonClick: function _onAnyButtonClick(index, event) {
        this.setState({
            active: index
        });

        this.props.onChange(index);
    }
});

Answer 1

This is my code .I do not know whether this is the best way ,as i started using react just 5 hrs ago. But it works fine.

var LeftPane = React.createClass({
    getInitialState: function() {
        return {list:[{name:"Item 1",isactive:1},
                      {name:"Item 2",isactive:0},
                      {name:"Item 3",isactive:0},                     
                      {name:"Item 4",isactive:0},
                      {name:"Item 5",isactive:0}]};
    },
    clickHandler: function(index) {
        var current_list = this.state.list;
        current_list.map(function(record,i){
          if(record.isactive==1){
            if(i!=index){
              record.isactive =0;
            }else{
              return;
            }
          }else{
            if(i==index){
              record.isactive =1;
            }
          }
        });
        this.setState({data:current_list}); 
    },   
    render: function() {
        var active_item = "list-group-item active"
        var non_active_item ="list-group-item";
        var _this = this;
        return (              
          <div className="list-group">
            {this.state.list.map(function(record,i) {                          
                if(record.isactive==1){
                return <a className={active_item} onClick={_this.clickHandler.bind(null, i)}>{record.name}</a>
                }else{
                return <a className={non_active_item} onClick={_this.clickHandler.bind(null, i)}>{record.name}</a>
                }                  
            })}
          </div>
        </div>
        )
    }
});

Answer 2

To get an api like this (similar to <input/>), we need to use the cloneWithProps addon.

  <RadioButtonGroup onChange={this.handleChange} value={this.state.selected}>
    <button>Test 1</button>
    <button>Test 2</button>
    <button>Test 3</button>
  </RadioButtonGroup>

All this does is take each child, add a click handler, and conditionally add a className of 'active' to it. You easily can (and should) modify it to take the active class name as a prop.

var RadioButtonGroup = React.createClass({
  render: function(){
    return <div>{React.Children.map(this.props.children, this.renderItem)}</div>
  },
  renderItem: function(button, index){
    return React.cloneElement(button, {
      className: this.props.value === index ? ' active ' : '',
      onClick: function(){ 
        this.props.onChange(index); 
      }.bind(this),
      key: index
    });
  }
});

demo

If you don't want to use cloneWithProps, you could use a wrapper div, but styling may be a bit more complex.

  renderItem: function(button, index){
    return React.createElement('div', {
      className: this.props.value === index ? ' active ' : '',
      onClick: function(){ 
        this.props.onChange(index); 
      }.bind(this),
      key: index
    }, button);
  }

The reason everything uses index is because you're passing react elements, which are opaque. There's no clean way to get any data out of these buttons, but we do know their index because we're iterating over them using React.Children.map. An alternative api would look like this:

<RadioButtonGroup value={'test1'} onChange={fn} options={{
   test1: <button>Test 1</button>,
   test2: <button>Test 2</button>,
   test3: <button>Test 3</button>
}} />

Here we can iterate over this.props.options, and pass the key to the onChange callback, and take e.g. 'test1' as a value prop.

Answer 3

I would not like to add onClick handler to every button element

React uses events delegation pattern, so you can freely adding as many onClick handlers as needs.

Another way, if you just want to make code clear, you may create your own button component, and pass _onActiveChange to it props, but i don't sure that it's necessary in your case.

And remember, that React works with synthetic events, and, in some cases, usage of setState within native event handlers may cause an unpredictable behaviour.

Answer 4

You don't want to mess with click handlers on each button, just listen for the click on the container. Then update the state based on which child is clicked.

Also, with React it's best to keep all of your DOM stuff in the render function. In this case, defining an element's class name.

Here's how this could work:

var RadioButtonGroup = React.createClass({
    getInitialState: function getInitialState() {
        return {
            active: this.props.active || 0
        };
    },

    clickHandler: function clickHandler(e) {
        // Getting an array of DOM elements
        // Then finding which element was clicked
        var nodes = Array.prototype.slice.call( e.currentTarget.children );
        var index = nodes.indexOf( e.target );
        this.setState({ active: index });
    },

    render: function render() {
        var buttons = this.children.map(function(child, i) {
            if (i === this.state.active) child.props.className += ' active';
            return child;
        }, this);

        return (
            <div className="radio-button-group" onClick={ this.clickHandler }>
                { buttons }
            </div>
        )
    }
});