Base template class data members are not visible i

Question

Consider the following C++ code,

template <typename Derived>
struct A
{
    bool usable_;
};

template <typename Derived>
struct B : A< B<Derived> >
{
    void foo()
    {
        usable_ = false;
    }
};

struct C : B<C>
{
    void foo()
    {
        usable_ = true;
    }
};

int main()
{
    C c;
}

I got compilation error: In member function void B<Derived>::foo():

template_inherit.cpp:12: error: 'usable_' was not declared in this scope.

Why is that ? Any good fix ?

Answer 1

That's because usable_ is a non-dependent name, so it is looked up at the time the template is parsed, instead of being looked up at instantiation (when the base class is known).

Unqualified name lookup will not lookup and non-dependent names are never looked up in dependent base classes. You can make the name usable_ dependent as follows, which will also get rid of unqualified name lookup

this->usable_ = false;

// equivalent to: A<B>::usable_ = false;
A< B<Derived> >::usable_ = false;

B::usable_ = false;

All of these will work. Or you can declare the name in the derived class with a using-declaration

template <typename Derived>
struct B : A< B<Derived> >
{
    using A< B<Derived> >::usable_;

    void foo()
    {
        usable_ = false;
    }
};

Note that in C there will be no problem - it only affects B.