Objective-C sub-classing basics, how to add custom

Question

I am having a issue subclassing MKPolygon.

I want to add a simple int tag property but I keep getting an instance of MKPolygon instead of my custom class, so calling setTag: causes an exception.

The problem is that MKPolygons are created using a class method: polygonWithCoordinates: count: and I dont know how to turn that into an instance of my class (which includes the tag property).

How would you go about adding a tag property to MKPolygon?

Thank you!

Answer 1

You should both use a category (as @Seva suggests) and objc_setAssociatedObject (as @hoha suggests).

@interface MKPolygon (TagExtensions)
@property (nonatomic) int tag;
@end

@implementation MKPolygon (TagExtensions)
static char tagKey;

- (void) setTag:(int)tag {
    objc_setAssociatedObject( self, &tagKey, [NSNumber numberWithInt:tag], OBJC_ASSOCIATION_RETAIN );
}

- (int) tag {
    return [objc_getAssociatedObject( self, &tagKey ) intValue];
}

@end

You may also want to look at Associative References section of the ObjC Guide, in addition to the API @hoha linked to.

Answer 2

since it looks like the authors went out of their way to prevent you from subclassing (at least, that's one possible motivation for the public interface), consider using a form of composition:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Object_composition

Answer 3

SpecialPolygon *polygon = [SpecialPolygon polygonWithCoordinates:count:];
[polygon setInt: 3];

The key is that by using the SpecialPolygon factory method instead of the MKPolygon one, you'll get the desired SpecialPolygon subclass.

Answer 4

I'm facing the same problem. A simple solution is to just use the Title property of the MKPolygon to save what you would save in Tag. At least in my case where I don't need an object reference but a simple number, it works

Answer 5

Are you talking about MKPolygons created by your code, or elsewhere? If the former, just override the polygonWithStuff method. If the latter, consider a category over MKPolygon. Then all MKPolygons in your project will have a tag in them.

Answer 6

Looks like developers of MKPolygon didn't make it inheritance friendly. If all you want is to add some tag to this instances you can

1) keep a map (NSDictionary or CFDictionary) from MKPolygon instance addresses to tags. This solution works well if all tags are required in the same class they are set.

2) use runtime to attach tag to polygons directly - objc_setAssociatedObject (Objective-C Runtime Reference)