Difference between os.getenv and os.environ.get

Question

Is there any difference at all between both approaches?

>>> os.getenv('TERM')
'xterm'
>>> os.environ.get('TERM')
'xterm'

>>> os.getenv('FOOBAR', "not found") == "not found"
True
>>> os.environ.get('FOOBAR', "not found") == "not found"
True

They seem to have the exact same functionality.

Answer 1

While there is no functional difference between os.environ.get and os.getenv, there is a massive difference between os.putenv and setting entries on os.environ. os.putenv is broken, so you should default to os.environ.get simply to avoid the way os.getenv encourages you to use os.putenv for symmetry.

os.putenv changes the actual OS-level environment variables, but in a way that doesn't show up through os.getenv, os.environ, or any other stdlib way of inspecting environment variables:

>>> import os
>>> os.environ['asdf'] = 'fdsa'
>>> os.environ['asdf']
'fdsa'
>>> os.putenv('aaaa', 'bbbb')
>>> os.getenv('aaaa')
>>> os.environ.get('aaaa')

You'd probably have to make a ctypes call to the C-level getenv to see the real environment variables after calling os.putenv. (Launching a shell subprocess and asking it for its environment variables might work too, if you're very careful about escaping and --norc/--noprofile/anything else you need to do to avoid startup configuration, but it seems a lot harder to get right.)

Answer 2

See this related thread. Basically, os.environ is found on import, and os.getenv is a wrapper to os.environ.get, at least in CPython.

EDIT: To respond to a comment, in CPython, os.getenv is basically a shortcut to os.environ.get ; since os.environ is loaded at import of os, and only then, the same holds for os.getenv.

Answer 3

One difference observed (Python27):

os.environ raises an exception if the environmental variable does not exist. os.getenv does not raise an exception, but returns None

Answer 4

In Python 2.7 with iPython:

>>> import os
>>> os.getenv??
Signature: os.getenv(key, default=None)
Source:
def getenv(key, default=None):
    """Get an environment variable, return None if it doesn't exist.
    The optional second argument can specify an alternate default."""
    return environ.get(key, default)
File:      ~/venv/lib/python2.7/os.py
Type:      function

So we can conclude os.getenv is just a simple wrapper around os.environ.get.

Answer 5

In addition to the answers above:

$ python3 -m timeit -s 'import os' 'os.environ.get("TERM_PROGRAM")'
200000 loops, best of 5: 1.65 usec per loop

$ python3 -m timeit -s 'import os' 'os.getenv("TERM_PROGRAM")'
200000 loops, best of 5: 1.83 usec per loop