How to best store user information and user login

Question

I'm using Mysql and I was assuming it was better to separate out a users personal information and their login and password into two different tables and then just reference them between the two.

Note : To clarify my post, I understand the techniques of securing the password (hash, salt, etc). I just know that if I'm following practices from other parts of my life (investing, data backup, even personal storage) that in the worst case scenario (comprised table or fire) that having information split among tables provides the potential to protect your additional data.

Answer 1

You ought to store them in the same table, and use one-way encryption. MD5 will work, but is weak, so you might consider something like SHA1 or another method. There's no benefit to storing the 2 items in seperate tables.

Answer 2

I'll attempt to answer your original question. Having it all in one table is fine unless you just have a lot of personal information to gather. In that case it may make sense to split it up. That decision should be made based on the amount of personal information you're dealing with and how often it needs to be accessed.

I'd say most of the time I'd do something like this in a single table:

UserID, FirstName, LastName, Email, Password, TempPassword

But... if you're gathering much more than that. Say you're gathering phone, fax, birth date, biography, etc, etc. And if most of that information is rarely accessed then I'd probably put that in its own table and connect it with a one-to-one relationship. After all, the fewer columns you have on a table, the faster your queries against that table will be. And sometimes it makes sense to simplify the tables that are most accessed. There is a performance hit with the JOIN though whenever you do need to access that personal information, so that's something you'll have to consider.

EDIT -- You know what, I just thought of something. If you create an index on the username or email field (whichever you prefer), it'll almost completely eliminate the performance drawback of creating so many columns in a user table. I say that because whenever you login the WHERE clause will actually be extremely quick to find the username if it has an index and it won't matter if you have 100 columns in that table. So I've changed my opinion. I'd put it all in one table. ;)

In either case, since security seems to be a popular topic, the password should be a hash value. I'd suggest SHA1 (or SHA256 if you're really concerned about it). TempPassword should also use a hash and it's only there for the forgot password functionality. Obviously with a hash you can't decrypt and send the user their original password. So instead you generate a temporary password they can login with, and then force them to change their password again after login.