Node.js Express route naming and ordering: how is

Question

Say I've got a few GET routes on my Express application:

// music albums
app.get('/api/albums', routes.albums.getAlbums);
app.get('/api/albums/:id', routes.albums.getAlbum);
app.get('/api/albums/artwork', routes.albums.getAlbumArtwork);

and I attempt to hit them using the follow jQuery AJAX snippet:

$("#retrieveAlbumArtwork").on("click", function() {
    $.ajax({
        url: "api/albums/artwork",
        type: "GET",
        data: {
            artist: $("#albumArtist").val(),
            title: $("#albumTitle").val()
        },
        // ... callbacks and such

For some reason, this call hits the second handler, with the /:id parameter, instead of the explicit /artwork route. Swapping them like so makes them function as expected:

// music albums
app.get('/api/albums', routes.albums.getAlbums);
app.get('/api/albums/artwork', routes.albums.getAlbumArtwork);
app.get('/api/albums/:id', routes.albums.getAlbum);

Can someone explain exactly why this is happening? I would assume Express would be smart enough to identify an id param (/albums/23453243) versus a querystring (/albums/artwork?artist=artistName&title=albumTitle) and route appropriately, but this doesn't seem to be the case?

Answer 1

No it isn't. :id will match anything. So /api/albums/artwork is totally valid for that match. Express does support RegExp match also. So you could make an explicit numeric matching route using RegExp.

Another option is using app.param as explained in the API documentation here: https://expressjs.com/en/api.html#app.param

This allows you to define matching params for the router so you could have a URL like /api/albums/:albumId where :albumId has to be numeric, you could also validate an albumId at this point if you wished too.

But in all, the second way you are doing it fairly normal, generally I put static routes at the top, then dynamic routes, catch all, then error handlers.