Finding islands of zeros in a sequence

问题:

Imagine you have a very long sequence. What is the most efficient way of finding the intervals where the sequence is all zeros (or more precisely the sequence drops to near-zero values abs(X)<eps):

For simplicity, lets assume the following sequence:

sig = [1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0];

I\'m trying to get the following information:

startIndex   EndIndex    Duration
3            6           4
12           12          1
14           16          3
25           26          2
30           30          1

then using this information, we find the intervals with duration >= to some specified value (say 3), and returning the indices of the values in all these intervals combined:

indices = [3 4 5 6 14 15 16];

That last part is related to a previous question:

MATLAB: vectorized array creation from a list of start/end indices

This is what I have so far:

sig = [1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0];
len = length(sig);
thresh = 3;

%# align the signal with itself successively shifted by one
%# v will thus contain 1 in the starting locations of the zero interval
v = true(1,len-thresh+1);
for i=1:thresh
    v = v & ( sig(i:len-thresh+i) == 0 );
end

%# extend the 1\'s till the end of the intervals
for i=1:thresh-1
    v(find(v)+1) = true;
end

%# get the final indices
v = find(v);

I\'m looking to vectorize/optimize the code, but I\'m open to other solutions. I have to stress that space and time efficiencies are very important, since I\'m processing a large number of long bio-signals.

回答1:

These are the steps I would take to solve your problem in a vectorized way, starting with a given vector sig:

• First, threshold the vector to get a vector tsig of zeros and ones (zeroes where the absolute value of the signal drops close enough to zero, ones elsewhere):

  tsig = (abs(sig) >= eps);  %# Using eps as the threshold
  

• Next, find the starting indices, ending indices, and duration of each string of zeroes using the functions DIFF and FIND:

  dsig = diff([1 tsig 1]);
  startIndex = find(dsig < 0);
  endIndex = find(dsig > 0)-1;
  duration = endIndex-startIndex+1;
  

• Then, find the strings of zeroes with a duration greater than or equal to some value (such as 3, from your example):

  stringIndex = (duration >= 3);
  startIndex = startIndex(stringIndex);
  endIndex = endIndex(stringIndex);
  

• Finally, use the method from my answer to the linked question to generate your final set of indices:

  indices = zeros(1,max(endIndex)+1);
  indices(startIndex) = 1;
  indices(endIndex+1) = indices(endIndex+1)-1;
  indices = find(cumsum(indices));
  

回答2:

You can solve this as a string search task, by finding strings of zeros of length thresh (STRFIND function is very fast)

startIndex = strfind(sig, zeros(1,thresh));

Note that longer substrings will get marked in multiple locations but will eventually be joined once we add in-between locations from intervals start at startIndex to end at start+thresh-1.

indices = unique( bsxfun(@plus, startIndex\', 0:thresh-1) )\';

Note that you can always swap this last step with the CUMSUM/FIND solution by @gnovice from the linked question.

回答3:

function indice=sigvec(sig,thresh)
    %extend sig head and tail to avoid 0 head and 0 tail

    exsig=[1,sig,1];
    %convolution sig with extend sig
    cvexsig=conv(exsig,ones(1,thresh));
    tempsig=double(cvexsig==0);

    indice=find(conv(tempsig,ones(1,thresh)))-thresh;

回答4:

the above answer by genovice can be modified to find the indices of non-zero elements in a vector as:

    tsig = (abs(sig) >= eps);
    dsig = diff([0 tsig 0]);
    startIndex = find(dsig > 0);
    endIndex = find(dsig < 0)-1;
    duration = endIndex-startIndex+1;

回答5:

As gnovice showed, we\'ll do a threshold test to make \"near zero\" really zero:

logcl = abs(sig(:)) >= zero_tolerance;

Then find regions where the cumulative sum isn\'t increasing:

cs = cumsum(logcl);
islands = cs(1+thresh:end) == cs(1:end-thresh);

Remembering gnovice\'s great method for filling in ranges of indexes

v = zeros(1,max(endInd)+1);   %# An array of zeroes
v(startInd) = 1;              %# Place 1 at the starts of the intervals
v(endInd+1) = v(endInd+1)-1;  %# Add -1 one index after the ends of the intervals
indices = find(cumsum(v));  %# Perform a cumulative sum and find the nonzero entries

We note that our islands vector already has ones in the startInd locations, and for our purposes endInd always comes thresh spots later (longer runs have runs of ones in islands)

endcap = zeros(thresh,1);
indices = find(cumsum([islands ; endcap] - [endcap ; islands]))

Test

sig = [1 1 0 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 0 1 0 0 0 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 0 0 1 1 1 0];
logcl = abs(sig(:)) >= .1;
cs = cumsum(logcl);
islands = cs(1+thresh:end) == cs(1:end-thresh);
endcap = zeros(thresh,1);
indices = find(cumsum([islands ; endcap] - [endcap ; islands]))

indices =

     2
     3
     4
     5
    13
    14
    15

回答6:

I think the most MATLAB/\"vectorized\" way of doing it is by computing a convolution of your signal with a filter like [-1 1]. You should look at the documentation of the function conv. Then on the output of conv use find to get the relevant indexes.