What are CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE: Debug, Release, RelWith

问题:

From the docs page:

CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE

Specifies the build type on single-configuration generators.

This statically specifies what build type (configuration) will be built in this build tree. Possible values are empty, Debug, Release, RelWithDebInfo and MinSizeRel. This variable is only meaningful to single-configuration generators (such as Makefile Generators and Ninja) i.e. those which choose a single configuration when CMake runs to generate a build tree as opposed to multi-configuration generators which offer selection of the build configuration within the generated build environment. There are many per-config properties and variables (usually following clean SOME_VAR_<CONFIG> order conventions), such as CMAKE_C_FLAGS_<CONFIG>, specified as uppercase: CMAKE_C_FLAGS_[DEBUG|RELEASE|RELWITHDEBINFO|MINSIZEREL]. For example, in a build tree configured to build type Debug, CMake will see to having CMAKE_C_FLAGS_DEBUG settings get added to the CMAKE_C_FLAGS settings. See also CMAKE_CONFIGURATION_TYPES.

I'm aware the differences between Debug builds and Release builds, but what are the differences between Release, RelWithDebInfo and MinSizeRel? I'm guessing RelWithDebInfo meant creating debuggable binaries, and MinSizeRel meant creating smallest possible size binaries.

From the LLVM CMake page:

CMAKE_BUILD_TYPE:STRING

If you are using an IDE such as Visual Studio, you should use the IDE settings to set the build type. Be aware that Release and RelWithDebInfo use different optimization levels on most platforms.

If I want to generate a production build, should I choose Release?

回答1:

RelWithDebInfo is the same as Release, allowing you to have symbol files for debugging.

For example in Visual Studio, you'll have .pdb files and without them, it'll be hard to debug because all the signatures in the binary files are not going to be human readable and there's no way to map them to the source code.

MinSizeRel is the same as Release, with its optimization configuration just set to Minimize size, Maximize speed in Visual Studio, for example.

If I want to generate a production build, should I choose Release?

Yes, that should do the right job for you. Debug/Release are the most commonly used options.

Reading this CMAKE FAQ will actually help you a lot.

回答2:

Yes, you are correct:

I'm guessing RelWithDebInfo meant creating debuggable binaries, and MinSizeRel meant creating smallest possible size binaries.

RelWithDebInfo will add compiler flags for generating debug information (the -g flag for GCC / clang), and will result in debuggable, yet much larger binaries.

MinSizeRel will add compiler flags for generating more compact binaries (the -Os flag for GCC / clang), possibly on the expense of program speed.

If I want to generate a production build, should I choose Release?

Yes, Release would be a good choice. It should produce faster binaries, by specifying compiler optimization level for favoring speed (-O3 for GCC / clang), and not including debug symbols.