Solving the mutating table problem in Oracle SQL p

问题:

Hey, I'm trying to create a trigger in my Oracle database that changes all other records except the one that has just been changed and launched the trigger to 0. Because I am updating records in the same table as the one that launched the trigger I got the mutating table error. To solve this, I put the code as an anonymous transaction, however this causes a deadlock.

Trigger code:

CREATE OR REPLACE TRIGGER check_thumbnail AFTER INSERT OR UPDATE OF thumbnail ON photograph
FOR EACH ROW
BEGIN
  IF :new.thumbnail = 1 THEN
    check_thumbnail_set_others(:new.url);
  END IF;
END;

Procedure code:

CREATE OR REPLACE PROCEDURE check_thumbnail_set_others(p_url IN VARCHAR2)
IS PRAGMA AUTONOMOUS_TRANSACTION;
BEGIN
    UPDATE photograph SET thumbnail = 0 WHERE url <> p_url;
    COMMIT;
END;

I assume I'm causing a deadlock because the trigger is launching itself within itself. Any ideas?

回答1:

Using an autonomous transaction for this sort of thing is almost certainly a mistake. What happens if the transaction that inserted the new thumbnail needs to rollback? You've already committed the change to the other rows in the table.

If you want the data to be transactionally consistent, you would need multiple triggers and some way of storing state. The simplest option would be to create a package with a collection of thumbnail.url%type then create three triggers on the table. A before statement trigger would clear out the collection. A row-level trigger would insert the :new.url value into the collection. An after statement trigger would then read the values from the collection and call the check_thumbnail_set_others procedure (which would not be an autonomous transaction).