What are the advantages of a companion object over

问题:

Kotlin code like this:

class Foo {
  companion object {
     fun a() : Int = 1
  }
  fun b() = a() + 1
}

can trivially be changed to

object FooStatic {
   fun a() : Int = 1
}

class Foo {
  fun b() = FooStatic.a()
}

I'm aware that the companion object can be used to allow use as real java static function, but are there any other advantages to using the companion object?

回答1:

One of the key differences is visibility of the members. In a companion object, visibility to the containing class is as-if the members were part of the class - this is not the case for a raw object.

The example below shows that you cant use an "object" to implement private static internals of a class.

package com.example

class Boo {

    companion object Boo_Core {
        // Public "static" call that non-Boo classes should not be able to call
        fun add_pub(a:Int) = a+1;

        // Internal "static" call that non-Boo classes should not be able to call
        private fun add_priv(a:Int) = a+1;
    }

    // OK: Functions in Boo can call the public members of the companion object
    fun blah_pub(a:Int) = add_pub(a)
    // OK: Functions in Boo can call the private members of the companion object
    fun blah_priv(a:Int) = add_priv(a)
}

//Same idea as the companion object, but as an "object" instead.
object Foo_Core {
    fun add_pub(a:Int) = a+1
    private fun add_priv(a:Int) = a+1;
}

class Foo {
    // OK Foo can get Foo_Cors add_pub
    fun blah_pub(a:Int) = Foo_Core.add_pub(a);

    // ERROR: can not get to add_priv
    // fun blah_priv(a:Int) = Foo_Core.add_priv(a);
}

class AnInterloper {

    // OK Other classes can use public entries in Foo.
    fun blah_foo_pub(a:Int) = Foo_Core.add_pub(a); 

    // ERROR Other classes can use public entries in Foo.
    // fun blah_foo_priv(a:Int) = Foo_Core.add_priv(a); 

    // OK: Other classes can use public Boo classes
    fun blah_boo_pub(a:Int) = Boo.add_pub(a);

    // ERROR: Other classes can not use private Boo classes
    // fun blah_boo_priv(a:Int) = Boo.add_priv(a);
}