How can I test my Bash script on older versions of

问题:

I'm working on a Bash library and want to ensure I'm supporting as many environments as possible - including old installations of Bash. My development environment is Bash 4.3, but some of my users may well be running much older versions and presently I have no way to confirm or deny that my library will work for them. In particular I'd like to be compatible with OSX (which still ships with Bash 3.2, AFAIK).

I know Bash can run in POSIX-compliant mode; is there a similar setting to disable modern functionality? Or a way to run Bash in some sort of compatibility mode? I'm looking for any technique short of actually finding and booting up old operating systems and testing my library there.

Update

For example, I've avoided using associative arrays since they were introduced in Bash 4, but it's hard to be sure without testing that I'm not accidentally using some other Bash 4+ feature.

回答1:

Finally coming back to this question, it's pretty easy to just compile (without installing) the bash version(s) you're interested in. Here's how I'm testing Bash 3.2.57:

$ mkdir ~/bash
$ cd ~/bash
$ wget http://ftp.gnu.org/gnu/bash/bash-3.2.57.tar.gz
$ tar xvzf bash-3.2.57.tar.gz
$ cd bash-3.2.57
$ ./configure
$ make
# if `make` fails due to yacc, run `sudo apt-get install byacc`
# No need to run `make install`
$ ./bash -version
GNU bash, version 3.2.57(1)-release (armv7l-unknown-linux-gnu)
Copyright (C) 2007 Free Software Foundation, Inc.

Now you have a bash 3.2.57 binary you can run, without actually "installing" it or modifying your normal environment.

To run a shell script against this version:

$ ./bash your_script.sh

To enter a clean interactive prompt:

$ env -i PATH="$PWD:$PATH" ./bash --noprofile --norc
bash-3.2$ bash -version
GNU bash, version 3.2.57(1)-release (armv7l-unknown-linux-gnu)
Copyright (C) 2007 Free Software Foundation, Inc.
bash-3.2$ 

Using env -i rather than just calling ./bash directly leaves you with a mostly-empty environment (run env from inside the shell to see what's still set). Updating the PATH allows calls to bash (e.g. bash -version) to invoke the local bash shell, not the system-wide installation (but note this pulls in your whole PATH). Adding --noprofile --norc avoids loading your .bashrc and associated scripts.

If you don't want to pick up any PATH modifications, just execute export PATH="$PWD:$PATH" once inside the subshell instead of as part of the env command.

---

These installation steps are now part of a Docker image, if that's helpful for folks to reference. I wouldn't necessarily suggest using this image directly, but you're welcome to copy from the Dockerfile. MIT licensed.

回答2:

Have a look at shenv: https://github.com/shenv/shenv. Just like rbenv, pyenv, goenv and others, but for shells, it lets you install different versions of Bash among others (zsh, fish, yash, etc.).

(Disclaimer: I'm the one who forked pyenv into shenv!)

回答3:

You can use Bash own facilities to emulate older version of Bash. Look up "compat" options on shopt.

Mind you, while it does change behavior as described under each compatNN entry in the man page, it does not remove features that are otherwise present on the current version. For example, this doesn't cause any errors:

shopt -s compat31
shopt -s globstar

Even though globstar was only introduced on Bash 4.0.