Do I need extra XSS security for ASP.NET 4 website

问题:

From what I understand about what ASP.NET does and my own personal testing of various XSS tests, I found that my ASP.NET 4 website does not require any XSS prevention.

Do you think that an ASP.NET 4.0 website needs any added XSS security than its default options? I cannot enter any javascript or any tags into my text fields that are then immediately printed onto the page.

回答1:

Disclaimer - this is based on a very paranoid definition of what "trusted output" is, but when it comes to web security, I don't think you CAN be too paranoid.

Taken from the OWASP page linked to below: Untrusted data is most often data that comes from the HTTP request, in the form of URL parameters, form fields, headers, or cookies. But data that comes from databases, web services, and other sources is frequently untrusted from a security perspective. That is, it might not have been perfectly validated.

In most cases, you do need more protection if you are taking input from ANY source and outputting it to HTML. This includes data retrieved from files, databases, etc - much more than just your textboxes. You could have a website that is perfectly locked down and have someone go directly to the database via another tool and be able to insert malicious script.

Even if you're taking data from a database where only a trusted user is able to enter the data, you never know if that trusted user will inadvertently copy and paste in some malicious script from a website.

Unless you absolutely positively trust any data that will be output on your website and there is no possible way for a script to inadvertently (or maliciously in case of an attacker or disgruntled employee) put dangerous data into the system, you should sanitize all output.

If you haven't already, familiarize yourself with the info here: https://www.owasp.org/index.php/XSS_%28Cross_Site_Scripting%29_Prevention_Cheat_Sheet

and go through the other known threats on the site as well.

In case you miss it, the Microsoft.AntiXss library is a very good tool to have at your disposal. In addition to a better version of the HtmlEncode function, it also has nice features like GetSafeHtmlFragment() for when you WANT to include untrusted HTML in your output and have it sanitized. This article shows proper usage: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa973813.aspx The article is old, but still relevant.

回答2:

Sorry Dexter, ASP.NET 4 sites do require XSS protection. You're probably thinking that the inbuilt request validation is sufficient and whilst it does an excellent job, it's not foolproof. It's still essential that you validate all input against a whitelist of acceptable values.

The other thing is that request validation is only any good for reflective XSS, that is XSS which is embedded in the request. It won't help you at all with persistent XSS so if you have other data sources where the input validation has not been as rigorous, you're at risk. As such, you always need to encode your output and encode it for the correct markup context (HTML, JavaScript, CSS). AntiXSS is great for this.

There's lots more info specifically as it relates to ASP.NET in OWASP Top 10 for .NET developers part 2: Cross-Site Scripting (XSS).