How does `db.serialize` work in `node-sqlite3`

问题:

Recently I'm learning to use node and node-sqlite3 to manipulate sqlite3, here is a sample.

var sqlite3 = require('sqlite3');
var db = new sqlite3.Database(':memory:');
db.serialize(function() {
    db.run("CREATE TABLE test(info TEXT)");
    db.run("INSERT INTO test (info) VALUES ('info1')");
})
db.close();

The documentation said that db.serialized was used to ensure SQL lines were executed in order, but I was confused, why wouldn't they get executed in order without db.serialize, after all they would be pulled from the event queue and executed in order? How does it work here?

And if there is only one sql to be executed, is it safe to run it without db.serialize as follows?

var sqlite3 = require('sqlite3');
var db = new sqlite3.Database(':memory:');
db.run("CREATE TABLE test(info TEXT)");
db.close();

回答1:

Each command inside the serialize() function is guaranteed to finish executing before the next one starts.

In your example, the CREATE TABLE will finish before the INSERT gets run. If you didn't use serialize() then the CREATE TABLE and INSERT statements would be run in parallel. They would start so quickly one after the other that the INSERT may actually finish before the table has been created, giving you an error about trying to insert data into a table that doesn't exist.

This is called a race condition, because every time you run your program you might get a different winner. If CREATE TABLE wins the race then the program will work fine. But if INSERT wins the race, the program will break with an error. Since you can't control who wins the race, serialize() will stop INSERT from even starting until CREATE TABLE has reached the end, ensuring you get the same outcome every time.

In your second example with only one statement then serialize() is still required. This is because run() starts the SQL query but returns immediately, leaving the query to run in the background. Since your very next command is one to close() the database, you'll cut it off while the query is still running.

Since serialize() doesn't return until the last of its internal queries has completed, using it will hold off the close() until the query has completed.

If you were using a different type of query (say in response to a user clicking a button on a web page, where the database is left open between calls) then you probably wouldn't need serialize(). It just depends whether the code that follows each query requires that the queries before it have completed or not.

When deciding whether to use serialize() or not, it can be helpful to think of any non-serialized queries as if they are commented out, and then see if the code would still work. In your first example above, removing the CREATE TABLE command would break the following INSERT statement (because then there'd be no table to insert into), therefore these need to be serialised. But if you had two CREATE TABLE commands then removing one would not affect the other, so those two commands would not have to be serialized.

(This tip doesn't apply to close() however - the rule of thumb there is to only call close() once everything has finished running.)

回答2:

I found this in the SQLite documentation:

the Database#close method will always run in exclusive mode, meaning it waits until all previous queries have completed and node-sqlite3 will not run any other queries while a close is pending.

So it looks like the answer to your final question is yes. If you only have one query to run, there's no need for the serialize function. You don't need to worry about your database getting closed before the query finishes because SQLite is smart enough not to do that! :)