Does the C++ standard library have a set ordered b

问题:

Does the C++ standard library have an "ordered set" datastructure? By ordered set, I mean something that is exactly the same as the ordinary std::set but that remembers the order in which you added the items to it.

If not, what is the best way to simulate one? I know you could do something like have a set of pairs with each pair storing the number it was added in and the actual value, but I dont want to jump through hoops if there is a simpler solution.

回答1:

No single, homogeneous data structure will have this property, since it is either sequential (i.e. elements are arranged in insertion order) or associative (elements are arranged in some order depending on value).

The best, clean approach would perhaps be something like Boost.MultiIndex, which allows you to add multiple indexes, or "views", on a container, so you can have a sequential and an ordered index.

回答2:

Instead of making a std::set of whatever type you're using, why not pass it a std::pair of the object and an index that gets incremented at each insertion?

回答3:

No, it does not.

Such a container presumably would need two different iterators, one to iterate in the order defined by the order of adding, and another to iterate in the usual set order. There's nothing of that kind in the standard libraries.

One option to simulate it is to have a set of some type that contains an intrusive linked list node in addition to the actual data you care about. After adding an element to the set, append it to the linked list. Before removing an element from the set, remove it from the linked list. This is guaranteed to be OK, since pointers to set elements aren't invalidated by any operation other than removing that element.

回答4:

I thought the answer is fairly simple, combine set with another iteratable structure (say, queue). If you like to iterate the set in the order that the element been inserted, push the elements in queue first, do your work on the front element, then pop out, put into set.

回答5:

Yes, it's called a vector or list (or array). Just appends to the vector to add element to the set.