When to use printf/scanf vs cout/cin?

问题:

I'm testing some snippets I found off the web using g++ from MinGW. This is the C++ compiler...why then does it correctly compile C....why do people intertwine C and C++.

The concrete question is: Is it O.K. to use both C and C++ and compile under g++. If the answer is yes, this makes my life easy as I do not have to modify the code.

Oddly enough...to get some C++ to work, particularly when passing a string to an ifstream constructor it requires a C type string...

My guess would be that because C++ depends upon C constructs at times is is O.K to write the two languages together.

However as a matter of style you should settle on cout/cin or printf/scanf.

回答1:

There are a few oddities where char* is needed. You can bridge the gap by using the .c_str() method of a std::string to get one.

For the most part, the C subset of C++ is compatible. Exactly how it isn't compatible is not likely to matter for the most part:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compatibility_of_C_and_C%2B%2B

If you're compiling snippets of C code under a C++ compiler, be sure to change it to use the "c" lib format in your includes...for example #include <cstdio> instead of #include <stdio.h>

Is it bad practice to use a C header instead of its C++ equivalent in C++ (e.g. stdio.h instead of cstdio)?

For a fairly reasoned argument from Bjarne himself on why to avoid scanf, check out the beginning of this paper:

http://www2.research.att.com/~bs/new_learning.pdf

There are a lot of benefits to using iostreams instead of printf as well:

'printf' vs. 'cout' in C++

回答2:

The C++ language inherits much of its core functionality from C. That's because C++ was derived from C. The C++ Standard includes, by reference much of the C Standard. Therefore you can use the C++ compiler to write code using C constructs, idioms and paradigms. Doing so is often referred to as using C++ "as a better C."

The long and the short of the above is yes, you can use printf in C++ code. Doing so is explicitly allowed by the Standard.

Doing this however will often neglect many of the features that define C++. I'll leave that conversation for another question but suffice it to say that many people will tell you simply "don't do that" or "that's not C++." This sets aside the reasons why you might not want to use printf in a C++ program or indeed why you would want to. But rest assured that it is technically allowed.

回答3:

Is it O.K. to use both C and C++ and compile under g++.

Yes, it is fine to mix the two languages. This is common with code that started out as C, but then got more and more C++ features added (obviously somebody changed the compiler along the way).

Generally, C code will compile and run with a C++ compiler. There are many possible exceptions, such as use of keywords like class and virtual for names of things in C code, or C's relaxed casting rules.

You will often hear people say "they are very different languages". That's because any programming question you ask probably has a different answer depending on which language you're trying to use. However, there are lots of similarities and backwards compatibility aspects as well.

回答4:

If you use C++, then use C++. (cin,cout)
Why fstream takes c string puzzles me too.