Accessing a Private Constructor from Outside the C

问题:

If I define a class with a private default constructor and a public constructor that has parameters, how can I access the private constructor?

public class Bob
{
   public String Surname { get; set; }

   private Bob()
   { }

   public Bob(string surname)
   {
      Surname = surname;
   }
}

I can access the private constructor via a static method on the class like this:

public static Bob GetBob()
{
   return new Bob();
}

I thought that I could access the private constructor via an extension method, since (according to my understanding) extension methods are translated so that they appear to be static methods on the class, but I can't:

static class Fred
{
   public static Bob Bobby(this Bob bob)
   {
      return new Bob();
   }
}

So, how can I access the private constructor?

Thank you

---

EDIT:

The reason that I wanted to do this was that I wanted to create tests for one of our business classes, but not allow a consumer of this class to be able to instantiate an object incorrectly. I'm testing it, so I know (I hope!) under what circumstances the tests will fail. I'm still a testing n00b right now so my idea may or may not have been the "wrong way" of doing things.

I've changed my testing strategy to just do things the way the a consumer of this class would, i.e. calling the public methods and if the public methods are OK, assuming that the private methods are OK. I would still prefer to test the private methods, but my boss is breathing down my neck on a deliverable :-(

回答1:

Default constructors are private for a reason. The developer doesn't make it private for fun.

But if you still want to use the default constructor you get it by using reflection.

var constructor = typeof(Bob).GetConstructor(BindingFlags.NonPublic|BindingFlags.Instance, null, new Type[0], null);
var instance = (Bob)constructor.Invoke(null);

Edit

I saw your comment about testing. Never test protected or private methods / properties. You have probably done something wrong if you can't manage to test those methods/properties through the public API. Either remove them or refactor the class.

Edit 2

Forgot a binding flag.

回答2:

There are several ways around this issue:

One: Make the constructor public. If you need to access it from outside the class why is it private (it might be that you only want to access the private constructor for testing, in which case this is a valid issue).

Two: Make the constructor protected, then access it through a derived class:

public class Bob
{
    public String Surname { get; set; }

    protected Bob()
    { }

    public Bob(string surname)
    {
        Surname = surname;
    }
}

public class Fred : Bob
{
    public Fred()
        : base()
    {
    }
}

Three: Use reflection (as shown by jgauffin).

回答3:

In additional to @jgauffin's answer which tells how to call private constructors via reflection:

Is it possible to change the modifiers of the private constructor?

It seems that you are implementing Factory Pattern in your code. Thus the modifier is supposed to be internal.

public class Product
{
   //others can't create instances directly outside the assembly
   internal Product() { }    
}
public class ProductProvider
{
   //they can only get standardized products by the provider
   //while you have full control to Product class inside ProductProvider
   public static Product CreateProduct()
   {
       Product p = new Product();    
       //standardize the product
       return p;
   }  
}

Extension methods

public static MyExt
{
   public static void DoSomething(this Product p) { }
}

Calling p.DoSomething() actually equals to MyExt.DoSomething(p). It's not putting this method into class Product.

回答4:

You can instantiate instances of that type via reflection.

回答5:

The method Bobby is still in a different class, called Fred. That is why you can't access the prive constructor of the Bob class. What you are trying to do is not possible with attached methods. Even if they can be attached on another class they are still declared outside that class and follow the usual scope/access rules.

回答6:

If you're using dotnet core you can do the following without even having to fiddle with any reflection:

YourCustomObject player = (YourCustomObject)Activator.CreateInstance(typeof(YourCustomObject),true);

回答7:

public class demo
{
   private demo()
    {
        Console.WriteLine("This is no parameter private constructor");
    }
    public demo(int a)
    {
        demo d = new demo('c');// u can call both private contstructors from here
        demo dd = new demo();
        Console.WriteLine("This is one parameter public constructor");
    }
    private demo(char a)
    {
        Console.WriteLine("This is one parameter public constructor::" + a);
    }
}

class Program
{
    static void Main(string[] args)
    {
        demo obj = new demo(7);
        // demo obj = new demo();  // it will raise error
        Console.ReadLine();
    }
}