Why does Default behave like this?

问题:

One may set a Default value for the arguments of a function:

Default[f] = 5;

And then use:

f[a_, b_.] := {a, b}

f[1, 2]
f[1]

   {1, 2}

   {1, 5}

This creates the following Values:

DefaultValues[f]
DownValues[f]

   {HoldPattern[Default[f]] :> 5}

   {HoldPattern[f[a_, b_.]] :> {a, b}}

From this one might think that the value 5 is not fixed in the definition of f, but addresses the DefaultValues assignment. However, if we change the DefaultValues, either directly or using:

Default[f] = 9;

DefaultValues[f]

   {HoldPattern[Default[f]] :> 9}

and use f again:

f[1]

   {1, 5}

we see that the new value is not used.

Therefore, my questions are:

• Why does the default value used by f[a_, b_.] := {a, b} not change with DefaultValues?

• Where is the real default value (5) stored, since it does not appear in either DownValues or DefaultValues?

回答1:

Not an answer, but:
Using the behaviour that the original default is kept until the function is redefined suggests a quick work-around:

Define a global variable for the Default before any other definitions are made.

In[1]:= Default[f]:=$f
In[2]:= f[a_.]:=a

In[3]:= f[]
Out[3]= $f

In[4]:= $f=5; f[]
Out[5]= 5
In[6]:= $f=6; f[]
Out[7]= 6
In[8]:= $f=.; f[]
Out[9]= $f

This also works for Optional

In[1]:= g[a_:$g] := a

In[2]:= g[]
Out[2]= $g

In[3]:= $g=1; g[]
Out[4]= 1

回答2:

From the documentation,

The necessary values for Default[f] must always be defined before _. is used as an argument of f.

Redefining f after setting Default[f] = 9; uses the new default value. So my guess is it is defined internally the first time, f is defined, and doesn't change even if DefaultValue@f stores the new value.

回答3:

I have found that this behavior in the case of local rules is due to specifics of internals of RuleDelayed.

Compare:

In[1]:= Default[f] = 5;
replaceAll[f[1], 
  f[a_, b_.] :> Unevaluated@{a, b}] /. (Default[f] = 9; replaceAll) ->
   ReplaceAll

Default[f] = 5;
Block[{RuleDelayed}, 
 replaceAll[f[1], 
   f[a_, b_.] :> Unevaluated@{a, b}] /. (Default[f] = 9; 
    replaceAll) -> ReplaceAll]

Out[2]= {1, 5}

Out[4]= Unevaluated[{1, 9}]

One can see that Blocking RuleDelayed makes local rules to behave as one could expect.