How dangerous is a mongo query which is fed direct

问题:

I am playing around with node.js, express, and mongoose.

For the sake of getting something up and running right now I am passing the Express query string object directly to a mongoose find function. What I am curious about is how dangerous would this practice be in a live app. I know that a RDBMS would be extremely vulnerable to SQL injection. Aside from the good advice of "sanitize your inputs" how evil is this code:

app.get('/query', function (req, res) {
    models.findDocs(req.query, function (err, docs) {
            res.send(docs);
        });
});

Meaning that a a get request to http://localhost:8080/query?name=ahsteele&status=a would just shove the following into the findDocs function:

{
  name: 'ahsteele',
  status: 'a'
}

This feels icky for a lot of reasons, but how unsafe is it? What's the best practice for passing query parameters to mongodb? Does express provide any out of the box sanitization?

回答1:

As far as injection being problem, like with SQL, the risk is significantly lower... albeit theoretically possible via an unknown attack vector.

The data structures and protocol are binary and API driven rather than leveraging escaped values within a domain-specific-language. Basically, you can't just trick the parser into adding a ";db.dropCollection()" at the end.

If it's only used for queries, it's probably fine... but I'd still caution you to use a tiny bit of validation:

• Ensure only alphanumeric characters (filter or invalidate nulls and anything else you wouldn't normally accept)
• Enforce a max length (like 255 characters) per term
• Enforce a max length of the entire query
• Strip special parameter names starting with "$", like "$where" & such
• Don't allow nested arrays/documents/hashes... only strings & ints

Also, keep in mind, an empty query returns everything. You might want a limit on that return value. :)

回答2:

Operator injection is a serious problem here and I would recommend you at least encode/escape certain characters, more specifically the $ symbol: http://docs.mongodb.org/manual/faq/developers/#dollar-sign-operator-escaping

If the user is allowed to append a $ symbol to the beginning of strings or elements within your $_GET or $_POST or whatever they will quickly use that to: http://xkcd.com/327/ and you will be a gonner, to say the least.

回答3:

As far as i know Express doesnt provide any out of box control for sanitization. Either you can write your own Middleware our do some basic checks in your own logic.And as you said the case you mention is a bit risky.

But for ease of use the required types built into Mongoose models at least give you the default sanitizations and some control over what gets into or not.

E.g something like this

var Person = new Schema({
  title   : { type: String, required: true }
, age     : { type: Number, min: 5, max: 20 }
, meta    : {
      likes : [String]
    , birth : { type: Date, default: Date.now }
  }

});

Check this for more info also.

http://mongoosejs.com/docs/2.7.x/docs/model-definition.html