What is TMonitor in Delphi System unit good for?

问题:

After reading the articles "Simmering Unicode, bring DPL to a boil" and "Simmering Unicode, bring DPL to a boil (Part 2)" of "The Oracle at Delphi" (Allen Bauer), Oracle is all I understand :)

The article mentions Delphi Parallel Library (DPL), lock free data structures, mutual exclusion locks and condition variables (this Wikipedia article forwards to 'Monitor (synchronization)', and then introduces the new TMonitor record type for thread synchronization and describes some of its methods.

Are there introduction articles with examples which show when and how this Delphi record type can be used? There is some documentation online.

• What is the main difference between TCriticalSection and TMonitor?

• What can I do with the Pulse and PulseAllmethods?

• Does it have a counterpart for example in C# or the Java language?

• Is there any code in the RTL or the VCL which uses this type (so it could serve as an example)?

---

Update: the article Why Has the Size of TObject Doubled In Delphi 2009? explains that every object in Delphi now can be locked using a TMonitor record, at the price of four extra bytes per instance.

It looks like TMonitor is implemented similar to Intrinsic Locks in the Java language:

Every object has an intrinsic lock associated with it. By convention, a thread that needs exclusive and consistent access to an object's fields has to acquire the object's intrinsic lock before accessing them, and then release the intrinsic lock when it's done with them.

Wait, Pulse and PulseAll in Delphi seem to be counterparts of wait(), notify() and notifyAll() in the Java programming language. Correct me if I am wrong :)

---

Update 2: Example code for a Producer/Consumer application using TMonitor.Wait and TMonitor.PulseAll, based on an article about guarded methods in the Java(tm) tutorials (comments are welcome):

This kind of application shares data between two threads: the producer, that creates the data, and the consumer, that does something with it. The two threads communicate using a shared object. Coordination is essential: the consumer thread must not attempt to retrieve the data before the producer thread has delivered it, and the producer thread must not attempt to deliver new data if the consumer hasn't retrieved the old data.

In this example, the data is a series of text messages, which are shared through an object of type Drop:

program TMonitorTest;

// based on example code at http://download.oracle.com/javase/tutorial/essential/concurrency/guardmeth.html

{$APPTYPE CONSOLE}

uses
  SysUtils, Classes;

type
  Drop = class(TObject)
  private
    // Message sent from producer to consumer.
    Msg: string;
    // True if consumer should wait for producer to send message, false
    // if producer should wait for consumer to retrieve message.
    Empty: Boolean;
  public
    constructor Create;
    function Take: string;
    procedure Put(AMessage: string);
  end;

  Producer = class(TThread)
  private
    FDrop: Drop;
  public
    constructor Create(ADrop: Drop);
    procedure Execute; override;
  end;

  Consumer = class(TThread)
  private
    FDrop: Drop;
  public
    constructor Create(ADrop: Drop);
    procedure Execute; override;
  end;

{ Drop }

constructor Drop.Create;
begin
  Empty := True;
end;

function Drop.Take: string;
begin
  TMonitor.Enter(Self);
  try
    // Wait until message is available.
    while Empty do
    begin
      TMonitor.Wait(Self, INFINITE);
    end;
    // Toggle status.
    Empty := True;
    // Notify producer that status has changed.
    TMonitor.PulseAll(Self);
    Result := Msg;
  finally
    TMonitor.Exit(Self);
  end;
end;

procedure Drop.Put(AMessage: string);
begin
  TMonitor.Enter(Self);
  try
    // Wait until message has been retrieved.
    while not Empty do
    begin
      TMonitor.Wait(Self, INFINITE);
    end;
    // Toggle status.
    Empty := False;
    // Store message.
    Msg := AMessage;
    // Notify consumer that status has changed.
    TMonitor.PulseAll(Self);
  finally
    TMonitor.Exit(Self);
  end;
end;

{ Producer }

constructor Producer.Create(ADrop: Drop);
begin
  FDrop := ADrop;
  inherited Create(False);
end;

procedure Producer.Execute;
var
  Msgs: array of string;
  I: Integer;
begin
  SetLength(Msgs, 4);
  Msgs[0] := 'Mares eat oats';
  Msgs[1] := 'Does eat oats';
  Msgs[2] := 'Little lambs eat ivy';
  Msgs[3] := 'A kid will eat ivy too';
  for I := 0 to Length(Msgs) - 1 do
  begin
    FDrop.Put(Msgs[I]);
    Sleep(Random(5000));
  end;
  FDrop.Put('DONE');
end;

{ Consumer }

constructor Consumer.Create(ADrop: Drop);
begin
  FDrop := ADrop;
  inherited Create(False);
end;

procedure Consumer.Execute;
var
  Msg: string;
begin
  repeat
    Msg := FDrop.Take;
    WriteLn('Received: ' + Msg);
    Sleep(Random(5000));
  until Msg = 'DONE';
end;

var
  ADrop: Drop;
begin
  Randomize;
  ADrop := Drop.Create;
  Producer.Create(ADrop);
  Consumer.Create(ADrop);
  ReadLn;
end.

Now this works as expected, however there is a detail which I could improve: instead of locking the whole Drop instance with TMonitor.Enter(Self);, I could choose a fine-grained locking approach, with a (private) "FLock" field, using it only in the Put and Take methods by TMonitor.Enter(FLock);.

If I compare the code with the Java version, I also notice that there is no InterruptedException in Delphi which can be used to cancel a call of Sleep.

Update 3: in May 2011, a blog entry about the OmniThreadLibrary presented a possible bug in the TMonitor implementation. It seems to be related to an entry in Quality Central. The comments mention a patch has been provided by a Delphi user, but it is not visible.

Update 4: A blog post in 2013 showed that while TMonitor is 'fair', its performance is worse than that of a critical section.

回答1:

TMonitor combines the notion of a critical section (or a simple mutex) along with a condition variable. You can read about what a "monitor" is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monitor_%28synchronization%29.

Anyplace you would use a critical section, you can use a monitor. Instead of declaring a TCriticalSection, you can simple create a TObject instance and then use that.

TMonitor.Enter(FLock);
try
  // protected code
finally
  TMonitor.Exit(FLock);
end;

Where FLock is any object instance. Normally, I just create a TObject:

FLock := TObject.Create;