Creating a window manager for Linux

问题:

I want to create a simple stacking window manager (in C) for private use, mainly for the purpose of learning and challenging myself.

I've looked through twm's source code which has relatively few bells and whistles but it seems very low level since it's not based on a widget toolkit.¹ Would using a toolkit such as GTK+ be preferable? I'm afraid that some of the code and libraries in twm might be too antiquated (edit: deprecated) and I want the window manager to use relatively modern libraries. For the sake of understanding I would also be interested in suggestions how to start a window manager from scratch — there aren't many tutorials for this purpose.

Update: For those thinking of similar projects: I ended up using Common Lisp and the CLX library. tinywm-lisp served as a basis and the brilliant CLFSWM and Stumpwm were a great help. For reference I used the CLX — Common LISP X Interface (PDF warning) and #xlib on Freenode.

回答1:

Whatever you do, use XCB and not Xlib. It' modern, asynchronous, simpler and gives you direct access to the X11 protocol.

回答2:

A very minimalistic WM is wm2. I haven't read the source code and hence I don't know if it is a teaching example. Of course you can use libraries that already do much of the abstraction and drawing work for you like gdk and gtk. But since this project is only for personal learning, I'd go the hard way and use Xlib directly.

Here are some links that might be useful for you:

• The Xlib Manual
• Xlib Programming Manual (O'Reilly & Associates, Inc.)
• Inter-Client Communication Conventions Manual
• Extended Window Manager Hints

回答3:

Have a look at the code for dwm. The codebase is beautiful and easy to understand. The entire thing is about 2000 lines.

回答4:

I've written an in-depth tutorial series that shows you how to write an X11 window manager in C++:

• http://seasonofcode.com/posts/how-x-window-managers-work-and-how-to-write-one-part-i.html

In addition, you can check out a simple example window manager, basic_wm, at

• https://github.com/jichu4n/basic_wm

It's heavily commented for pedagogical purposes.

On Xlib vs XCB - I would recommend Xlib over XCB if you're first starting out. XCB is more efficient, but it's much more low-level and much more verbose (think assembly language for the GUI). You don't want to burden yourself with premature optimization until you already have a prototype working.

回答5:

http://code.google.com/p/partiwm/ is an attempt to write a window manager (tiling, not stacking) from scratch, it might be useful to you to read through the code.

回答6:

metacity uses gtk for certain UI elements. See its HACKING and README.

see also Where are some good Xlib programming guides?

回答7:

For the sake of understanding I would also be interested in suggestions how to start a window manager from scratch

You may want to have a look at the aewm window manager. The code is small and it does the basics quite well. It's written in C and uses Xlib.

http://www.red-bean.com/decklin/aewm/

回答8:

Xmonad might be a good place to start.