How do ASP.NET Core's “asp-fallback-*” CDN tag

问题:

I understand what the asp-fallback-* tag helpers do. What I don't understand is how.

For example:

<link rel="stylesheet"
      href="//ajax.aspnetcdn.com/ajax/bootstrap/3.3.5/css/bootstrap.min.css"
      asp-fallback-href="~/lib/bootstrap/dist/css/bootstrap.min.css"
      asp-fallback-test-class="sr-only"
      asp-fallback-test-property="position"
      asp-fallback-test-value="absolute" />

This loads bootstrap from the CDN, and loads the local copy if the CDN is down.

But how does it decide to do that? I assume it checks asp-fallback-test-class, asp-fallback-test-property, and asp-fallback-test-value. But what do those attributes mean?

If I want to hook up some other library off a CDN, I'll need to supply something for those, but I'm not sure what to put there.

There are lots of examples of this in action, but I can't find explanations about how this works.

UPDATE
I'm not really trying to understand how the tag helpers work - how they render, and so on. I'm trying to understand how to choose values for those attributes. For example, the jQuery fallback script usually has asp-fallback-test="window.jQuery" which makes sense - it's a test to see if jQuery has loaded. But the ones I've shown above are quite different. How does one choose them? If I want to use some other CDN delivered library, I'll need to specify values for those attributes... what would I use? Why were those ones chosen for bootstrap?

UPDATE 2
To understand how the fallback process itself works, and how those tags are written, see @KirkLarkin's answer. To understand why those test values were used, see my answer.

回答1:

TL;DR:

• A <meta> tag is added to the DOM that has a CSS class of sr-only.
• Additional JavaScript is written to the DOM, which:
  1. Locates said <meta> element.
  2. Checks whether said element has a CSS property position that is set to absolute.
  3. If no such property value is set, an additional <link> element is written to the DOM with a href of ~/lib/bootstrap/dist/css/bootstrap.min.css.

---

The LinkTagHelper class that runs against your <link> elements inserts a <meta> element in the output HTML that is given a CSS class of sr-only. The element ends up looking like this:

<meta name="x-stylesheet-fallback-test" content="" class="sr-only" />

The code that generates the element looks like this (source):

builder
    .AppendHtml("<meta name=\"x-stylesheet-fallback-test\" content=\"\" class=\"")
    .Append(FallbackTestClass)
    .AppendHtml("\" />");

Unsurprisingly, the value for FallbackTestClass is obtained from the <link>'s asp-fallback-test-class attribute.

Right after this element is inserted, a corresponding <script> block is also inserted (source). The code for that starts off like this:

// Build the <script /> tag that checks the effective style of <meta /> tag above and renders the extra
// <link /> tag to load the fallback stylesheet if the test CSS property value is found to be false,
// indicating that the primary stylesheet failed to load.
// GetEmbeddedJavaScript returns JavaScript to which we add '"{0}","{1}",{2});'
builder
    .AppendHtml("<script>")        
    .AppendHtml(JavaScriptResources.GetEmbeddedJavaScript(FallbackJavaScriptResourceName))
    .AppendHtml("\"")
    .AppendHtml(JavaScriptEncoder.Encode(FallbackTestProperty))
    .AppendHtml("\",\"")
    .AppendHtml(JavaScriptEncoder.Encode(FallbackTestValue))
    .AppendHtml("\",");

There are a few things of interest here:

• The last line of the comment, which refers to placeholders {0}, {1} and {2}.
• FallbackJavaScriptResourceName, which represents a JavaScript resource that is output into the HTML.
• FallbackTestProperty and FallbackTestValue, which are obtained from the attributes asp-fallback-test-property and asp-fallback-test-value respectively.

So, let's have a look at that JavaScript resource (source), which boils down to a function with the following signature:

function loadFallbackStylesheet(cssTestPropertyName, cssTestPropertyValue, fallbackHrefs, extraAttributes)

Combining this with the last line of the comment I called out earlier and the values of asp-fallback-test-property and asp-fallback-test-value, we can reason that this is invoked like so:

loadFallbackStylesheet('position', 'absolute', ...)

I won't dig into the fallbackHrefs and extraAttributes parameters as that should be somewhat obvious and easy to explore on your own.

The implementation of loadFallbackStylesheet does not do a great deal - I encourage you to explore the full implementation on your own. Here's the actual check from the source:

if (metaStyle && metaStyle[cssTestPropertyName] !== cssTestPropertyValue) {
    for (i = 0; i < fallbackHrefs.length; i++) {
        doc.write('<link href="' + fallbackHrefs[i] + '" ' + extraAttributes + '/>');
    }
}

The script obtains the relevant <meta> element (it's assumed to be directly above the <script> itself) and simply checks that it has a property of position that is set to absolute. If it does not, additional <link> elements are written to the output for each fallback URL.

回答2:

Ok I think I get it now, by combining @KirkLarkin's answer and common sense.

The sr-only is applied to a hidden meta element. If bootstrap is loaded then that element would get a css value of position:absolute. So that is tested, and if it's so, then it means Bootstrap has been loaded.

So for any library, you need to choose a good example of something only that library can do, and style a hidden <meta> tag accordingly, then specify which css style to test, and what value you are expecting.

For javscript it's even easier, because you can just test for the library itself, which usually has some well known variable added to the window or something to the DOM. So for jQuery it's window.jQuery, and for Bootstrap it can be tested as window.jQuery && window.jQuery.fn && window.jQuery.fn.modal and so on.