How to search for a node in a tree and return it?

问题:

I'm trying to search for a node in a binary tree and return in case it's there, otherwise, return null. By the way, the node class has a method name() that return a string with it's name...What I have so far is:

private Node search(String name, Node node){

     if(node != null){
         if(node.name().equals(name)){
            return node;
         }

      else{
         search(name, node.left);
         search(name, node.right);
      }
    }
    return null;
}

Is this correct??

回答1:

You need to make sure your recursive calls to search return if the result isn't null.

Something like this should work...

private Node search(String name, Node node){
    if(node != null){
        if(node.name().equals(name)){
           return node;
        } else {
            Node foundNode = search(name, node.left);
            if(foundNode == null) {
                foundNode = search(name, node.right);
            }
            return foundNode;
         }
    } else {
        return null;
    }
}

回答2:

public Node findNode(Node root, Node nodeToFind) {
    Node foundNode = null;
    Node traversingNode = root;

    if (traversingNode.data == nodeToFind.data) {
        foundNode = traversingNode;
        return foundNode;
    }

    if (nodeToFind.data < traversingNode.data
            && null != traversingNode.leftChild) {
        findNode(traversingNode.leftChild, nodeToFind);
    } else if (nodeToFind.data > traversingNode.data
            && null != traversingNode.rightChild) {
        findNode(traversingNode, nodeToFind);
    }

    return foundNode;

}

回答3:

Since language doesn't matter much for this question, here's what it looks in C# with pre-order traversal:

public static Node FindNode(Node n, int nodeValue)
{
    if (n == null) return null;
    if (n.Value == nodeValue) return n;
    return FindNode(n.Left, nodeValue) ?? FindNode(n.Right, nodeValue);
}

回答4:

you should return something if it is found in node.left or node.right so the else block should be something like that:

 else{
     Node temp = search(name, node.left);
     if (temp != null) return temp;
     temp = search(name, node.right);
     if (temp != null) return temp;
  }

回答5:

you don't do anything with the result of the recursive calls

Node res = search(name, node.left);
if(res!=null)return res;
res = search(name, node.right);
if(res!=null)return res;

回答6:

This might be better:

if(node != null){
    if(node.name().equals(name)){
        return node;
    }
    else {
        Node tmp = search(name, node.left);
        if (tmp != null) { // if we find it at left
            return tmp; // we return it
        }
        // else we return the result of the search in the right node
        return search(name, node.right);
    }
}
return null;

回答7:

Boolean FindInBinaryTreeWithRecursion(TreeNode root, int data)
{
    Boolean temp;
    // base case == emptytree
    if (root == null) return false;
    else {
        if (data == root.getData())  return true;
        else { // otherwise recur down tree
            temp = FindInBinaryTreeWithRecursion(root.getLeft(), data);
            if (temp != true) 
                return temp;
            else
                return (FindInBinaryTreeWithRecursion(root.getRight(), data));  
        }
    }
}

回答8:

public static TreeNode findNodeInTree(TreeNode root, TreeNode nodeToFind) {
  if (root == null) {
    return null;
  }

  if (root.data == nodeToFind.data) {
    return root;
  }

  TreeNode found = null;
  if (root.left != null) {
    found = findNodeInTree(root.left, nodeToFind);
    if (found != null) {
      return found;
    }
  }

  if (root.right != null) {
    found = findNodeInTree(root.right, nodeToFind);
    if (found != null) {
      return found;
    }
  }
  return null;
}

回答9:

Actually, try to avoid recursivity. In case you have big tree structure you will get stack overflow error. Instead of this you can use a list:

private Node search(String name, Node node){
    List<Node> l = new ArrayList<Node>();
    l.add(node);
    While(!l.isEmpty()){
        if (l.get(0).name().equals(name))   
            return l.get(0);
        else {
            l.add(l.get(0).left);
            l.add(l.get(0).right);
            l.remove(0);
        }           
    }   
    return null;
}

回答10:

public static boolean findElement(Node root, int value) {
    if (root != null) {
        if (root.data == value) {
            return true;
        } else {
            return findElement(root.left, value) || findElement(root.right, value);
        }
    }
    return false;
}