Advantages/Drawbacks of “var” in Java 10 [closed]

问题:

Closed. This question is opinion-based. It is not currently accepting answers.

---

Want to improve this question? Update the question so it can be answered with facts and citations by editing this post.

Closed 2 years ago.

Improve this question

AFAIK, var is not keyword in Java. It is reserved type name. I wonder that in what circumstances we should use/avoid it. Are there principles about its usage?

import java.util.HashMap;

public class Test {
    public static void main(String[] args) {
        var x = new HashMap<> (); // legal
        var y = new HashMap<String, Integer>(); // legal

        var z = "soner"; // legal
        System.out.println(z);

        var umm = null;  // xx wrong xx //
        var foo; // xx wrong usage without initializer xx //

        var var = 5; // legal

    }
}

回答1:

I know one reason, that we actually use in our project. Whenever there is a variable that is "big" we replace it with var. For example:

 public void test(){
     CreateEmailEsignTransactionAsync job = new CreateEmailEsignTransactionAsync(... some input);

     // vs 
     var job = new CreateEmailEsignTransactionAsync(... some input)
 }

I find the second example a lot more readable, and this is how we mainly use it.

There is another example where this could be used (but I am not using it so far). Previously this was possible via chaining only for lambda expressions for example, as this would be a type known by the compiler only - they could not be declared.

 public void test() {
        var test = new Object() {
            public void go() {

            }
        };

        test.go();
    }

回答2:

I can see one drawback to use var aka "Local type-inference":

var x = "A";
// String x
var y = getInstance(x);
//? y

In that context, you need to check the signature of getInstance(String) method to know what will be y type.

EDIT:

Since there is a discussion about the name of my variables not being really correct, let's use some real example then.

 var sDate = "20180426";
 var date = DateUtil.getDate(sDate);

What type is date ?

I could call

 public static java.util.Date getDate(String);
 public static java.sql.Date getDate(String);
 public static java.time.LocalDate getDate(String);

I don't believe the solution would be to use a full name either.

 var javaUtilDate
 var javaSqllDate
 var javaTimeLocalDate

So instead, in that case I would not use type inference

var sDate = "20180426";
LocalDate date = DateUtil.getDate(sDate);

Note: Can someone tell me if this require the import of LocalDate if I use var (note that I use a method in a different class, so I never had to declare LocalDate in this class).
I will answer myself if I find the time to install a JDK10.

回答3:

You could use it for anonymous classes too, i.e. there is just no type to declare. E.g.

var r = new Runnable()
{
  int result1, result2;
  @Override public void run()
  {
    result1 = doStuff();
    result2 = doMoreStuff();
  }
}

makeSomething(r);
System.out.println(r.result1 * r.result2);