Why does Java code slow down in debugger?

问题:

Some CPU intensive routines get dramatically slower when run through a debugger. Why is this?

Currently I'm just using IntelliJ to step through code running in JBoss. When I start JBoss, I use these options:

set JAVA_OPTS=-Xms512m -Xmx1024m -XX:MaxPermSize=256m -Xdebug -Xrunjdwp:transport=dt_socket,address=5005,server=y,suspend=n %JAVA_OPTS%

Is there a way to speed up the execution? Or to speed up certain method executions that I don't need to step through?

---

Update: Seems if I don't step over/into the CPU intensive routines (ie: Just run til a breakpoint set right after the routine), then the execution time is as if not in a debugger.

回答1:

Some CPU intensive routines get dramatically slower when run through a debugger. Why is this?

Because the JITter won't optimize code as much (often, not at all) when debugging is enabled.

回答2:

It also depends on the "breakpoints-style". E.g. having watchpoints on variables or putting breakpoints on interface level (debugger will stop on all method-implementations when they're executed) often dramatically slows down the process time.

回答3:

When debugging, in addition to running your application, you are also running a debugger.

The code is compiled in debug mode with metadata symbols about local variables and other source-level information. The debugger reads to know which line of source code corresponds with the current instruction. The process is called symbolic debugging. The stored symbols increase code size and interpreting them increases execution time.

Some debuggers actually interpret the code on the fly, which is almost always a major performance hit.

More information about Java's debug compilation mode, which is performed by javac and includes debug information in class files: Java Language Compiler Options. For example: -g generates all debugging information, including local variables.

回答4:

You do need to consider that another program -- the debugger -- is hooked into your program and is watching it for things like exceptions. It's also monitoring the current line in order to react to breakpoints or user requested interruptions (like a pause request or watch condition).

回答5:

Debugging the optimized code produced by the JIT would be very hard, because there isn't a direct relationship between a range of native instructions and a line of Java code like there is a relationship between a range of Java bytecode and a line of Java code.

So breaking into a function in the debugger forces the JVM to deoptimize the method you are stepping through. Hotspot doesn't generate native code at all and just interprets the bytecode of the method.

Prior to JDK 1.4.1 starting with debugging enabled forced the JVM to only use the interpreter: http://java.sun.com/products/hotspot/docs/whitepaper/Java_Hotspot_v1.4.1/Java_HSpot_WP_v1.4.1_1002_3.html#full

回答6:

Top Tip: in IDEA you can use ALT+F9 to run to where you have the cursor placed rather than set an extra breakpoint.

I have found anecdotally that debugging becomes very slow in IDEA if you are walking through code where there is a lot of data accessible from the stack. Don't forget, IDEA collects this data (anything currently in the lexical scope) and presents it up to you as a tree of objects to browse whether you are "watching" or not and does this at every subsequent step (maybe it re-creates the tree each time?).

This is especially apparent when, for example, there is a large collection as an instance variable of the "current" object.

回答7:

If you use Java 5, the parameter for debugging is :

-agentlib:jdwp=transport=dt_socket,server=y,suspend=n,address=

and before Java 5

-Xdebug -Xrunjdwp:transport=dt_socket,address=5005,server=y,suspend=n