Coarse-grained vs fine-grained

问题:

What is the difference between coarse-grained and fine-grained?

I have searched these terms on Google, but I couldn't find what they mean.

回答1:

From Wikipedia (granularity):

Granularity is the extent to which a system is broken down into small parts, either the system itself or its description or observation. It is the extent to which a larger entity is subdivided. For example, a yard broken into inches has finer granularity than a yard broken into feet.

Coarse-grained systems consist of fewer, larger components than fine-grained systems; a coarse-grained description of a system regards large subcomponents while a fine-grained description regards smaller components of which the larger ones are composed.

回答2:

In simple terms

• Coarse-grained - larger components than fine-grained, large subcomponents. Simply wraps one or more fine-grained services together into a more coarse­-grained operation.
• Fine-grained - smaller components of which the larger ones are composed, lower­level service

It is better to have more coarse-grained service operations, which are composed by fine-grained operations

回答3:

Coarse-grained: A few ojects hold a lot of related data that's why services have broader scope in functionality. Example: A single "Account" object holds the customer name, address, account balance, opening date, last change date, etc. Thus: Increased design complexity, smaller number of cells to various operations

Fine-grained: More objects each holding less data that's why services have more narrow scope in functionality. Example: An Account object holds balance, a Customer object holds name and address, a AccountOpenings object holds opening date, etc. Thus: Decreased design complexity , higher number of cells to various service operations. These are relationships defined between these objects.

回答4:

One more way to understand would be to think in terms of communication between processes and threads. Processes communicate with the help of coarse grained communication mechanisms like sockets, signal handlers, shared memory, semaphores and files. Threads, on the other hand, have access to shared memory space that belongs to a process, which allows them to apply finer grain communication mechanisms.

Source: Java concurrency in practice

回答5:

In the context of services:

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Service_Granularity_Principle

By definition a coarse-grained service operation has broader scope than a fine-grained service, although the terms are relative. The former typically requires increased design complexity but can reduce the number of calls required to complete a task.

A fine grained service interface is about the same like chatty interface.

回答6:

In term of dataset like a text file ,Coarse-grained meaning we can transform the whole dataset but not an individual element on the dataset While fine-grained means we can transform individual element on the dataset.

回答7:

Coarse-grained and Fine-grained both think about optimizing a number of servicess. But the difference is in the level. I like to explain with an example, you will understand easily.

Fine-grained: For example, I have 100 services like findbyId, findbyCategry, findbyName...... so on. Instead of that many services why we can not provide find(id, category, name....so on). So this way we can reduce the services. This is just an example, but the goal is how to optimize the number of services.

Coarse-grained: For example, I have 100 clients, each client have their own set of 100 services. So I have to provide 100*100 total services. It is very much difficult. Instead of that what I do is, I identify all common services which apply to most of the clients as one service set and remaining separately. For example in 100 services 50 services are common. So I have to manage 100*50 + 50 only.

回答8:

Coarse-grained granularity does not always mean bigger components, if you go by literally meaning of the word coarse, it means harsh, or not appropriate. e.g. In software projects management, if you breakdown a small system into few components, which are equal in size, but varies in complexities and features, this could lead to a coarse-grained granularity. In reverse, for a fine-grained breakdown, you would divide the components based on their cohesiveness of the functionalities each component is providing.

回答9:

coarse grained and fine grained. Both of these modes define how the cores are shared between multiple Spark tasks. As the name suggests, fine-grained mode is responsible for sharing the cores at a more granular level. Fine-grained mode has been deprecated by Spark and will soon be removed.

回答10:

Corse-grained services provides broader functionalities as compared to fine-grained service. Depending on the business domain, a single service can be created to serve a single business unit or specialised multiple fine-grained services can be created if subunits are largely independent of each other. Coarse grained service may get more difficult may be less adaptable to change due to its size while fine-grained service may introduce additional complexity of managing multiple services.