I'm trying to model this inheritance for a simple blog system
Blog has many Entries, but they may be different in their nature. I don't want to model the Blog table, my concern is about the entries:
- simplest entry is an
Article that has title and text
Quote, however, does not have a title and has short textMedia has a url and a comment...- etc...
What is a proper way to model this with Ruby on Rails? That is
- Should I use ActiverRecord for this or switch to DataMapper?
- I would like to avoid the "one big table" approach with lots of empty cells
When I split the data into Entry + PostData, QuoteData etc can I have belongs_to :entry in these Datas without having has_one ??? in the Entry class? That would be standard way to do it in sql and entry.post_data may be resolved by the entry_id in the postdata table.
EDIT: I don't want to model the Blog table, I can do that, my concern is about the entries and how would the inheritance be mapped to the table(s).
I've come across this data problem several times and have tried a few different strategies. I think the one I'm a biggest fan of, is the STI approach as mentioned by cicloon. Make sure you have a type column on your entry table.
class Blog < ActiveRecord::Base
# this is your generic association that would return all types of entries
has_many :entries
# you can also add other associations specific to each type.
# through STI, rails is aware that a media_entry is in fact an Entry
# and will do most of the work for you. These will automatically do what cicloon.
# did manually via his methods.
has_many :articles
has_many :quotes
has_many :media
end
class Entry < ActiveRecord::Base
end
class Article < Entry
has_one :article_data
end
class Quote < Entry
has_one :quote_data
end
class Media < Entry
has_one :media_data
end
class ArticleData < ActiveRecord::Base
belongs_to :article # smart enough to know this is actually an entry
end
class QuoteData < ActiveRecord::Base
belongs_to :quote
end
class MediaData < ActiveRecord::Base
belongs_to :media
end
The thing I like about this approach, is you can keep the generic Entry data in the entry model. Abstract out any of the sub-entry type data into their own data tables, and have a has_one association to them, resulting in no extra columns on your entries table. It also works very well for when you're doing your views:
app/views/articles/_article.html.erb
app/views/quotes/_quote.html.erb
app/views/media/_media.html.erb # may be medium here....
and from your views you can do either:
<%= render @blog.entries %> <!-- this will automatically render the appropriate view partial -->
or have more control:
<%= render @blog.quotes %>
<%= render @blog.articles %>
You can find a pretty generic way of generating forms as well, I usually render the generic entry fields in an entries/_form.html.erb partial. Inside that partial, I also have a
<%= form_for @entry do |f| %>
<%= render :partial => "#{f.object.class.name.tableize}/#{f.object.class.name.underscore}_form", :object => f %>
<% end %>
type render for the sub form data. The sub forms in turn can use accepts_nested_attributes_for + fields_for to get the data passed through properly.
The only pain I have with this approach, is how to handle the controllers and route helpers. Since each entry is of its own type, you'll either have to create custom controllers / routes for each type (you may want this...) or make a generic one. If you take the generic approach, two things to remember.
1) You can't set a :type field through update attributes, your controller will have to instantiate the appropriate Article.new to save it (you may use a factory here).
2) You'll have to use the becomes() method (@article.becomes(Entry)) to work with the entry as an Entry and not a subclass.
Hope this helps.
Warning, I've actually used Media as a model name in the past. In my case it resulted in a table called medias in rails 2.3.x however in rails 3, it wanted my model to be named Medium and my table media. You may have to add a custom Inflection on this naming, though I'm not sure.
You can handle this easily using ActiveRecord STI. It requires you to have a type field in your Entries table. This way you can define your models like this:
def Blog > ActiveRecord::Base
has_many :entries
def articles
entries.where('Type =', 'Article')
end
def quotes
entries.where('Type =', 'Quote')
end
def medias
entries.where('Type =', 'Media')
end
end
def Entry > ActiveRecord::Base
belongs_to :blog
end
def Article > Entry
end
def Quote > Entry
end
def Media > Entry
end
