可以将文章内容翻译成中文,广告屏蔽插件可能会导致该功能失效(如失效,请关闭广告屏蔽插件后再试):
问题:
Has anyone had good experiences with any Java libraries for Graph algorithms. I\'ve tried JGraph and found it ok, and there are a lot of different ones in google. Are there any that people are actually using successfully in production code or would recommend?
To clarify, I\'m not looking for a library that produces graphs/charts, I\'m looking for one that helps with Graph algorithms, eg minimum spanning tree, Kruskal\'s algorithm Nodes, Edges, etc. Ideally one with some good algorithms/data structures in a nice Java OO API.
回答1:
If you were using JGraph, you should give a try to JGraphT which is designed for algorithms. One of its features is visualization using the JGraph library. It\'s still developed, but pretty stable. I analyzed the complexity of JGraphT algorithms some time ago. Some of them aren\'t the quickest, but if you\'re going to implement them on your own and need to display your graph, then it might be the best choice. I really liked using its API, when I quickly had to write an app that was working on graph and displaying it later.
回答2:
Summary:
- JGraphT if you are more interested in data structures and algorithms.
- JGraph if your primary focus is visualization.
- Jung, yWorks, and BFG are other things people tried using.
- Prefuse is a no no since one has to rewrite most of it.
- Google Guava if you need good datastructures only.
- Apache Commons Graph. Currently dormant, but provides implementations for many algorithms. See https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SANDBOX-458 for a list of implemented algorithms, also compared with Jung, GraphT, Prefuse, jBPT
回答3:
Check out JGraphT for a very simple and powerful Java graph library that is pretty well done and, to allay any confusion, is different than JGraph. Some sample code:
UndirectedGraph<String, DefaultEdge> g =
new SimpleGraph<String, DefaultEdge>(DefaultEdge.class);
String v1 = \"v1\";
String v2 = \"v2\";
String v3 = \"v3\";
String v4 = \"v4\";
// add the vertices
g.addVertex(v1);
g.addVertex(v2);
g.addVertex(v3);
g.addVertex(v4);
// add edges to create a circuit
g.addEdge(v1, v2);
g.addEdge(v2, v3);
g.addEdge(v3, v4);
g.addEdge(v4, v1);
回答4:
JUNG is a good option for visualisation, and also has a fairly good set of available graph algorithms, including several different mechanisms for random graph creation, rewiring, etc. I\'ve also found it to be generally fairly easy to extend and adapt where necessary.
回答5:
Apache Commons offers commons-graph. Under http://svn.apache.org/viewvc/commons/sandbox/graph/trunk/ one can inspect the source. Sample API usage is in the SVN, too. See https://issues.apache.org/jira/browse/SANDBOX-458 for a list of implemented algorithms, also compared with Jung, GraphT, Prefuse, jBPT
Google Guava if you need good datastructures only.
JGraphT is a graph library with many Algorithms implemented and having (in my oppinion) a good graph model. Helloworld Example. License: LGPL+EPL.
JUNG2 is also a BSD-licensed library with the data structure similar to JGraphT. It offers layouting algorithms, which are currently missing in JGraphT. The most recent commit is from 2010 and packages hep.aida.*
are LGPL (via the colt library, which is imported by JUNG). This prevents JUNG from being used in projects under the umbrella of ASF and ESF. Maybe one should use the github fork and remove that dependency. Commit f4ca0cd is mirroring the last CVS commit. The current commits seem to remove visualization functionality. Commit d0fb491c adds a .gitignore
.
Prefuse stores the graphs using a matrix structure, which is not memory efficient for sparse graphs. License: BSD
Eclipse Zest has built in graph layout algorithms, which can be used independently of SWT. See org.eclipse.zest.layouts.algorithms. The graph structure used is the one of Eclipse Draw2d, where Nodes are explicit objects and not injected via Generics (as it happens in Apache Commons Graph, JGraphT, and JUNG2).
回答6:
http://neo4j.org/ is a graph database that contains many of graph algorithms and scales better than most in-memory libraries.
回答7:
In a university project I toyed around with yFiles by yWorks and found it had pretty good API.
回答8:
check out Blueprints:
Blueprints is a collection of interfaces, implementations, ouplementations, and test suites for the property graph data model. Blueprints is analogous to the JDBC, but for graph databases. Within the TinkerPop open source software stack, Blueprints serves as the foundational technology for:
Pipes: A lazy, data flow framework
Gremlin: A graph traversal language
Frames: An object-to-graph mapper
Furnace: A graph algorithms package
Rexster: A graph server
回答9:
http://incubator.apache.org/hama/ is a distributed scientific package on Hadoop for massive matrix and graph data.
回答10:
JDSL (Data Structures Library in Java) should be good enough if you\'re into graph algorithms - http://www.cs.brown.edu/cgc/jdsl/
回答11:
For visualization our group had some success with prefuse. We extended it to handle architectural floorplates and bubble diagraming, and it didn\'t complain too much. They have a new Flex toolkit out too called Flare that uses a very similar API.
UPDATE:
I\'d have to agree with the comment, we ended up writing a lot of custom functionality/working around prefuse limitations. I can\'t say that starting from scratch would have been better though as we were able to demonstrate progress from day 1 by using prefuse. On the other hand if we were doing a second implementation of the same stuff, I might skip prefuse since we\'d understand the requirements a lot better.
回答12:
Try Annas its an open source graph package which is easy to get to grips with
http://annas.googlecode.com
回答13:
It\'s also good to be convinced that a Graph can be represented as simply as :
class Node {
int value;
List<Node> adj;
}
and implement most the algorithms you find interesting by yourself. If you fall on this question in the middle of some practice/learning session on graphs, that\'s the best lib to consider. ;)
You can also prefer adjacency matrix for most common algorithms :
class SparseGraph {
int[] nodeValues;
List<Integer>[] edges;
}
or a matrix for some operations :
class DenseGraph {
int[] nodeValues;
int[][] edges;
}
回答14:
I don\'t know if I\'d call it production-ready, but there\'s jGABL.
回答15:
If you need performance, you might take a look at Grph. The library is developed in the French University and CNRS/Inria.
http://www.i3s.unice.fr/~hogie/grph/
The project is active and reactive support is provided!
回答16:
Instructional graph algorithm implementations in java could be found here (by prof. Sedgewick et al.):
http://algs4.cs.princeton.edu/code/
I was introduced to them while attending these exceptional algorithm courses on coursera (also taught by prof. Sedgewick):
https://www.coursera.org/course/algs4partI
https://www.coursera.org/course/algs4partII
回答17:
If you are actually looking for Charting libraries and not for Node/Edge Graph libraries I would suggest splurging on Big Faceless Graph library (BFG). It\'s way easier to use than JFreeChart, looks nicer, runs faster, has more output options, really no comparison.
回答18:
JGraph from http://mmengineer.blogspot.com/2009/10/java-graph-floyd-class.html
Provides a powerfull software to work with graphs (direct or undirect). Also generates Graphivz code, you can see graphics representations. You can put your own code algorithms into pakage, for example: backtracking code. The package provide some algorithms: Dijkstra, backtracking minimun path cost, ect..