ASP.NET forms authentication keeps displaying logi

I have a web app which is displaying strange behaviour when used from an iPad. On occasion, it keeps displaying the login page, even though the user gets authenticated and I create a cookie which is stored on the client.

The app is an MVC2 app, and I am calling a controller method via ajax to perform the authentication. If the ajax call is successful then the client performs a window.location.assign() to navigate the user to the secure page.(I'm doing this to support full-screen iPad web app mode)

I use the following code to create the cookie:

string formsCookieStr = string.Empty;
FormsAuthenticationTicket ticket = new FormsAuthenticationTicket(
            1,                              // version
            username,                       // user name
            DateTime.Now,                   // issue time
            DateTime.Now.AddMinutes(30),    // expires
            false,                          // Persistence
            userRoleData                    // user data
    );
formsCookieStr = FormsAuthentication.Encrypt(ticket);
HttpCookie FormsCookie = new HttpCookie(FormsAuthentication.FormsCookieName, formsCookieStr);
HttpContext.Response.Cookies.Add(FormsCookie);

The url for the authentication is /Account/LogOn2. The url that is the 'secure' page is /Admin

If I look at the IIS logs (below) then I can see that the first call to /Account/LogOn2 is passing the correct username and password. The second log entry shows the GET that the ajax call subsequently makes, and you can clearly see that a new ASPXAUTH cookie accompanies the request - it is this cookie that was set following the first call. Why then is the second call resulting in a 302 (redirect), when the request is properly authenticated, as proven by the presence of the ASPXAUTH cookie in the second call? It is as if the server is not 'seeing' the authentication cookie and is forcing the 302 redirect. The third entry shows the redirect resulting in a request for the login form again.

2011-06-07 16:33:37 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /Account/LogOn2 username=pete&password=wine&returnUrl=%2fProfileList 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=214FCF8C485AD048B2A0833BCA77582097EBF8F88BC2B0A64D7CD4F2BD7B1D9CB0C4209DC82FFA93466A58462BCA7EAB0D35B8573CCC5AABDDD5F7ACD0D38FCCB7275A79606B990B8A189887F724BF4D30BF3F9474CCD872868FE6DB48A3825F8770116A1C142AAD99A195E5D46B7BD6DB8FCF709FDE79A6B4F70B99E9646B515946E82DD988231DCE8504E5B63134419A0A107CBB367ABC978BC71A5D7C2CEF;+ASP.NET_SessionId=5uu3m1db2iqgetgvmpjgnot2 200 0 0
2011-06-07 16:33:38 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /ProfileList - 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=644A6CC55F3E1E78922FA2E5FF7E54CBF11654F636A58142C10BBD9CB8FAF440FC8A642AAE02A7A4AACC0904D27B225A38DA2016EB09AA03D761916048C35711C7AC136A9A58C63956DBCC3ABBED9EE5818F19E07585A93EB00950F53B5D3934650CFE611AAC926BC8D6BDBEE67F2EC8675ACBC66E594D0EF2556910A037E3C9782E134F56F7CAE9F9E31AD69CDB9F0C68B9B81BE7075918F9ECBC39DA03A77F;+ASP.NET_SessionId=5uu3m1db2iqgetgvmpjgnot2 302 0 0
2011-06-07 16:33:39 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /Account/LogOn ReturnUrl=%2fProfileList 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=644A6CC55F3E1E78922FA2E5FF7E54CBF11654F636A58142C10BBD9CB8FAF440FC8A642AAE02A7A4AACC0904D27B225A38DA2016EB09AA03D761916048C35711C7AC136A9A58C63956DBCC3ABBED9EE5818F19E07585A93EB00950F53B5D3934650CFE611AAC926BC8D6BDBEE67F2EC8675ACBC66E594D0EF2556910A037E3C9782E134F56F7CAE9F9E31AD69CDB9F0C68B9B81BE7075918F9ECBC39DA03A77F;+ASP.NET_SessionId=5uu3m1db2iqgetgvmpjgnot2 200 0 0
2011-06-07 16:33:39 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 POST /Sync/Users - 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=644A6CC55F3E1E78922FA2E5FF7E54CBF11654F636A58142C10BBD9CB8FAF440FC8A642AAE02A7A4AACC0904D27B225A38DA2016EB09AA03D761916048C35711C7AC136A9A58C63956DBCC3ABBED9EE5818F19E07585A93EB00950F53B5D3934650CFE611AAC926BC8D6BDBEE67F2EC8675ACBC66E594D0EF2556910A037E3C9782E134F56F7CAE9F9E31AD69CDB9F0C68B9B81BE7075918F9ECBC39DA03A77F;+ASP.NET_SessionId=5uu3m1db2iqgetgvmpjgnot2 200 0 0
2011-06-07 16:33:39 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 POST /Sync/Profiles - 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=644A6CC55F3E1E78922FA2E5FF7E54CBF11654F636A58142C10BBD9CB8FAF440FC8A642AAE02A7A4AACC0904D27B225A38DA2016EB09AA03D761916048C35711C7AC136A9A58C63956DBCC3ABBED9EE5818F19E07585A93EB00950F53B5D3934650CFE611AAC926BC8D6BDBEE67F2EC8675ACBC66E594D0EF2556910A037E3C9782E134F56F7CAE9F9E31AD69CDB9F0C68B9B81BE7075918F9ECBC39DA03A77F;+ASP.NET_SessionId=5uu3m1db2iqgetgvmpjgnot2 200 0 0

Why is the server not 'seeing' the authentication cookie in the second request?

Thanks very much for reading this far. I'm tearing my hair out here!

EDIT: thought it might be useful to show the two IIS log entries that reflect a successful login:

2011-06-07 17:58:08 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /Account/LogOn2 username=pete&password=wine&returnUrl=%2fAdmin 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 - 200 0 0
2011-06-07 17:58:09 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /Admin - 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=4965435E85DA486CECFAC6234F7EB96E91608374522B842642C825328E12BB199809D4982BB55AA53BBDE7123679DD48D0518AF053EE6BC5AEBE653EA922BBBFB04CCCC7E369A2C42CDBF56F63DF184DE89D74F5632C3E6F007D8852177F37482A5E48A59B39DF9F8AC8271827ED15CFB70607E8960AAFFB12433C7D9391A15B1571740F888C5654AF5F52A50D2B9E1D21682A49C4DAA24686B19F888F92C255;+ASP.NET_SessionId=0q3ah5d1rkj5drkf0clrzwdi 200 0 0

Note the HTTP Status code 200 for the second entry.

EDIT Example of successful login then client-side load of /ProfileList

2011-06-07 17:49:10 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /Account/LogOn2 username=pete&password=wine&returnUrl=%2fProfileList 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 - 200 0 0
2011-06-07 17:49:13 W3SVC97442007 192.168.1.4 GET /ProfileList - 80 - 86.153.46.122 Mozilla/5.0+(iPad;+U;+CPU+OS+4_3_3+like+Mac+OS+X;+en-us)+AppleWebKit/533.17.9+(KHTML,+like+Gecko)+Mobile/8J3 .ASPXAUTH=26D4837E045282BF0F6118CABE52C0D1A264396BBDEE65E35502D77CD33AA39782B2F19D50971AD8C4F29BEF7DB268BF1F7359F1DBA58029C6BF1BFF6D95404B877F76D581FC8777F25030073CEB4D1ED5C591B532B41C212F772EC57717A50D063D4DAF195FCBFC4F2F6F88025043579E11D57030E6CFC51FB4250D8B3B99829E1446BD55B2C265A9153B23E2DC6D9419AA2E3E58AA01FC5760A5A7C44D69AE;+ASP.NET_SessionId=txvqo5pfod3bdg12d2llbh3g 200 0 0

回答1:

I believe I have the answer. You need to specifically set web.config to force the use of cookies. My authentication setting in web.config now looks like this:

<authentication mode="Forms">
      <forms loginUrl="~/Account/LogOn" timeout="2880" 
             cookieless="UseCookies" 
             />
    </authentication>

It is the cookieless="UseCookies" entry that solved the problem. The default value for this is UseDeviceProfile. It must have been the case that an iPad does not have a consistent UseDeviceProfile regime. On the iPad, sometimes it worked, sometimes it didn't. Don't ask me why. It now seems to be consistently working.

回答2:

Just to add I came across this problem in IE11. Any .net 4.0 app using forms authentication seems to get into an infinite redirect loop, must be something to do with the user agent.

The cookieless="UseCookies" config change also fixes the IE11 issue

回答3:

I've spent many hours on a similar issue with IE11 the other day and yes, the cookieless="UseCookies" seemed to have helped with the login ... but it didn't solve another problem ...

Turned out to be a problem with IIS 7 NOT recognizing IE11 as a modern browser and reverting its logic to a basic support with no cookies, no javascript support in the browser (IIS wouldn't send cookies or javascript code to the browser hence cookieless="UseCookies" would help with the cookies issue on login, but javascript was still a problem).

A solution I found was to add .browser definition files to my app's App_Browsers folder for FireFox and IE11 and I no longer needed the cookieless="UseCookies" option, at least for IE11

Unfortunately, I can't find any .browser files for the iPad and it seems one of my clients is having exactly the same issues as yours with their iPad... Perhaps someone else has found it and can share it here? If not, I'll keep trying to solve this and post my solution once I find it. Until then ... UseCookies must do.