Updated: Interacting with the user on the windows

问题:

@UPDATE:

OK FOR ANYONE ELSE WHO IS SEEKING ADVICE ON THIS ISSUE...

So far, the best thing I have found is to download yourself a copy of pGina and for 2k/XP modify the GINA, and for vista/win7 you will need to create custom login credentials (pGina have the tools/samples to interface with the Vista/Win7 architecture).

to confirm -- it appears that this is what Novell are doing with Vista/Win7 rather than the traditional method of replacing the GINA (like in 2k/XP)

If anyone else comes up with a way to run an application on the logon screen in Win7 please post it.

---

Ok I'm writing some vb6 software that requires input before the user logs on to the system.

Basically I want to run an application on the Windows logon screen where the user can interact with the program. At present I have the application running as a service allowing to interact with the desktop, but it is still now showing.

I know that "Allow service to interact with desktop" will work in Windows 2000 / XP, I'm running Windows 7 - I am also aware that services cannot directly interact with a user as of Windows Vista - saying this, are there any other methods to get my application running on the logon screen. Novell does it

Does anyone have any other ideas to get this working?

回答1:

You can only do this if you are authenticating the credentials yourself. Prior to Vista, this was done via GINA, but since Vista, you need to write your own Credential Provider.

The reasons behind this are buried deep in the security principles -- Ctrl-Alt-Del will only ever bring up the window station associated with login (etc), and no other application can get to that window station (so you can't create a fake password box over the top to scrape passwords, for instance).

Without knowing why you think your service needs to interact with that desktop, it's difficult to advise further, but it might mean that your design is broken somehow.

回答2:

Service isolation will probably prevent you doing this from a service.

Pre-vista Novell and the like would probably have used GINA, which was replaced in vista; http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-gb/magazine/cc163489.aspx

回答3:

The only way I know of would be to write your own msgina.dll.

It can get dicey during testing though. Any mistakes can mess up your OS so bad that a complete reinstall becomes necessary.