C#: Redirect Standard Output of a Process that is

问题:

I've been having a hard time getting the output of a "sub-process" (one launched internally by a blackbox process that I'm monitoring via c# System.Diagnostics.Process)

I took the advice given by the answer of my previous post: here. And there you can find the details of what I've been going through.

At this point, although I'm able to locate the ssh process spawned by process1.exe, that I'm monitoring. I can't redirect the output to my c# program, because it is an "already running process", and wasn't launched directly from C#.

It seems that, all the properties that you set on a System.Diagnostics.Process object, only take effect if you are explicitly launching that process from your c# application; if some other "unmanaged process" has launched the process, setting this redirection has no effect, because the process has already been launched by something that didn't specify the redirection I need.

Is there any way to redirect output of a process that has already been launched (a process launched by a program for which I have no scope to pre-specify redirection before this process is launched)?

回答1:

Assuming there's no more straightforward solution, you could try to run a piece a code in another process through CreateRemoteThread(), explained here.

回答2:

Instead of redirecting the output directly from the running process, can you capture the output as it leaves the process A at the intended destination, the pass it into your new process?

回答3:

Perhaps you can look at this code. I found it when searching for a solution to do the same kind of thing; however, it was not really inter-process.

If that doesn't help you might be able to look at P/Invoking SetStdHandle and GetStdHandle which are supposed to be used when redirecting standard output. I think this is what the code sample linked to does to make the redirection happen.

Note: I just looked at this stuff and didn't actually get it to work properly. (I had a better solution available to me because I had access to the source code outputting to the console)

回答4:

I've got the same conundrum. It's not an option for me to invoke anything internal in the slave process. It's already running, which code is beyond my control. But I do know it spits out Standard Output, which I want to monitor, process, etc. It's one thing I kick off the process, I can configure the redirection, but in this instance, the process will be launched secondarily to my kicking off the primary slave process. So I do not have that option. I haven't found a way for .NET Process to work under these conditions. Perhaps there is another way, maybe C++ is the way to go here? This would be marginally acceptable, but I would like to approach it from a .NET C# perspective if possible.