What is the colon operator in Ruby?

问题:

When I say { :bla => 1, :bloop => 2 }, what exactly does the : do? I read somewhere about how it's similar to a string, but somehow a symbol.

I'm not super-clear on the concept, could someone enlighten me?

回答1:

:foo is a symbol named "foo". Symbols have the distinct feature that any two symbols named the same will be identical:

"foo".equal? "foo"  # false
:foo.equal? :foo    # true

This makes comparing two symbols really fast (since only a pointer comparison is involved, as opposed to comparing all the characters like you would in a string), plus you won't have a zillion copies of the same symbol floating about.

Also, unlike strings, symbols are immutable.

回答2:

Just to demonstrate some of the things mentioned in the answers:

require 'benchmark'

n = 1_000_000

print '"foo".equal? "foo" -> ', ("foo".equal? "foo"), "\n"
print '"foo" == "foo"     -> ', ("foo" == "foo"    ), "\n"
print ':foo.equal? :foo   -> ', (:foo.equal? :foo  ), "\n"
print ':foo == :foo       -> ', (:foo == :foo      ), "\n"

Benchmark.bm(10) do |b|
  b.report('string')     { n.times { "foo".equal? "foo" }}
  b.report('str == str') { n.times { "foo" == "foo"     }}
  b.report('symbol')     { n.times { :foo.equal? :foo   }}
  b.report('sym == sym') { n.times { :foo == :foo       }}
end

Running it outputs:

"foo".equal? "foo" -> false
"foo" == "foo"     -> true
:foo.equal? :foo   -> true
:foo == :foo       -> true

So, comparing a string to a string using equal? fails because they're different objects, even if they are equal content. == compares the content, and the equivalent checks with symbols are much faster.

                 user     system      total        real
string       0.370000   0.000000   0.370000 (  0.371700)
str == str   0.330000   0.000000   0.330000 (  0.326368)
symbol       0.170000   0.000000   0.170000 (  0.174641)
sym == sym   0.180000   0.000000   0.180000 (  0.179374)

Both symbol tests are basically the same as far as speed. After 1,000,000 iterations there's only 0.004733 second difference, so I'd say it's a wash between which to use.

回答3:

Symbols are a way to represent strings and names in ruby.

The main difference between symbols and strings is that symbols of the same name are initialized and exist in memory only once during a session of ruby.

They are useful when you need to use the same word to represent different things

回答4:

There're some quotes from the famous book Agile Web Development with Rails, which may be helpful to understand the symbol as well :

Rails uses symbols to identify things. In particular, it uses them as keys when naming method parameters and looking things up in hashes.

redirect_to :action => "edit", :id => params[:id]

You can think of symbols as string literals that are magically made into constants. Alternatively, you can consider the colon to mean "the thing named", so :id is "the thing named id".

回答5:

In ruby each object has an unique object identifier, if you write puts "hello".object_id in your irb and hit return for 2 different times, you will get 2 different returning value,but if you write :hello.object_id 2 times you will only get the same one returning value. That should have explained the difference.

回答6:

If you use :foo => bar, foo will be a symbol. The benefit to symbols is that they are unique. When you call on an item in the hash, you do hash[:foo].

Symbols require less memory than strings, which also makes them useful if you want to make your program a little faster.

回答7:

It's a symbol. Basically, you are saying that the two elements of the hash have keys bla and bloop, much as if you had used the strings "bla" and "bloop". However, they take up less memory than strings and are easier to type.

回答8:

All these answers omit one extra tantalising detail.. if you stringify the symbol :foo, you get.. guess what.. the string "foo". Hence

irb(main):025:0>
irb(main):026:0> :foo
=> :foo
irb(main):027:0> "#{:foo}"
=> "foo"
irb(main):028:0>
irb(main):029:0> 'foo' <=> :foo
=> nil
irb(main):030:0> 'foo' <=> :foo.to_s
=> 0
irb(main):031:0>

Hence.. for Perl programmers.. it's Ruby's answer to the 'bare word'.

回答9:

If you are familiar with Java, you might be aware that Strings in Java are immutable. Symbols are similar in that sense in Ruby. They are immutable, i.e., any number of occurances of a particular symbol :symbol will map to only a single memory address. And, hence, it is recommended to use symbols wherever possible since it optimizes memory usage.