Html5 canvas drawImage: how to apply antialiasing

问题:

Please have a look at the following example:

http://jsfiddle.net/MLGr4/47/

    var canvas=document.getElementById(\"canvas\");
    var ctx=canvas.getContext(\"2d\");

    img=new Image();
    img.onload=function(){
        canvas.width=400;
        canvas.height=150;
        ctx.drawImage(img,0,0,img.width,img.height,0,0,400,150);
    }
    img.src=\"http://openwalls.com/image/1734/colored_lines_on_blue_background_1920x1200.jpg\";

As you see, the image is not anti-aliased although it is said that drawImage applies anti aliasing automatically. I tried many different ways but it doesn\'t seem to work. Could you please tell me how I can get anti-aliased image? Thanks.

回答1:

Cause

Some images are just very hard to down-sample and interpolate such as this one with curves when you want to go from a large size to a small.

Browsers appear to typically use bi-linear (2x2 sampling) interpolation with the canvas element rather than bi-cubic (4x4 sampling) for (likely) performance reasons.

If the step is too huge then there are simply not enough pixels to sample from which is reflected in the result.

From a signal/DSP perspective you could see this as a low-pass filter\'s threshold value set too high, which may result in aliasing if there are many high frequencies (details) in the signal.

Solution

Update 2018:

Here\'s a neat trick you can use for browsers which supports the filter property on the 2D context. This pre-blurs the image which is in essence the same as a resampling, then scales down. This allows for large steps but only needs two steps and two draws.

Pre-blur using number of steps (original size / destination size / 2) as radius (you may need to adjust this heuristically based on browser and odd/even steps - here only shown simplified):

const canvas = document.getElementById(\"canvas\");
const ctx = canvas.getContext(\"2d\");

if (typeof ctx.filter === \"undefined\") {
 alert(\"Sorry, the browser doesn\'t support Context2D filters.\")
}

const img = new Image;
img.onload = function() {

  // step 1
  const oc = document.createElement(\'canvas\');
  const octx = oc.getContext(\'2d\');
  oc.width = this.width;
  oc.height = this.height;

  // steo 2: pre-filter image using steps as radius
  const steps = (oc.width / canvas.width)>>1;
  octx.filter = `blur(${steps}px)`;
  octx.drawImage(this, 0, 0);

  // step 3, draw scaled
  ctx.drawImage(oc, 0, 0, oc.width, oc.height, 0, 0, canvas.width, canvas.height);

}
img.src = \"//i.stack.imgur.com/cYfuM.jpg\";

body{ background-color: ivory; }
canvas{border:1px solid red;}

<br/><p>Original was 1600x1200, reduced to 400x300 canvas</p><br/>
<canvas id=\"canvas\" width=400 height=250></canvas>

Support for filter as ogf Oct/2018:

CanvasRenderingContext2D.filter                                                   
api.CanvasRenderingContext2D.filter                                               
On Standard Track, Experimental                                                   
https://developer.mozilla.org/docs/Web/API/CanvasRenderingContext2D/filter        
                                                                                  
DESKTOP >        |Chrome    |Edge      |Firefox   |IE        |Opera     |Safari   
:----------------|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------
filter !         |    52    |    ?     |    49    |    -     |    -     |    -    
                                                                                  
MOBILE >         |Chrome/A  |Edge/mob  |Firefox/A |Opera/A   |Safari/iOS|Webview/A
:----------------|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------
filter !         |    52    |    ?     |    49    |    -     |    -     |    52   
                                                                                  
! = Experimental                                                                  
                                                                                  
Data from MDN - \"npm i -g mdncomp\" (c) epistemex

Update 2017: There is now a new property defined in the specs for setting resampling quality:

context.imageSmoothingQuality = \"low|medium|high\"

It\'s currently only supported in Chrome. The actual methods used per level is left to the vendor to decide, but it\'s reasonable to assume Lanczos for \"high\" or something equivalent in quality. This means step-down may be skipped altogether, or larger steps can be used with fewer redraws, depending on the image size and

Support for imageSmoothingQuality:

CanvasRenderingContext2D.imageSmoothingQuality
api.CanvasRenderingContext2D.imageSmoothingQuality
On Standard Track, Experimental
https://developer.mozilla.org/docs/Web/API/CanvasRenderingContext2D/imageSmoothingQuality

DESKTOP >              |Chrome    |Edge      |Firefox   |IE        |Opera     |Safari
:----------------------|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:
imageSmoothingQuality !|    54    |    ?     |    -     |    ?     |    41    |    Y

MOBILE >               |Chrome/A  |Edge/mob  |Firefox/A |Opera/A   |Safari/iOS|Webview/A
:----------------------|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:|:--------:
imageSmoothingQuality !|    54    |    ?     |    -     |    41    |    Y     |    54

! = Experimental

Data from MDN - \"npm i -g mdncomp\" (c) epistemex

browser. Until then..:
End of transmission

The solution is to use step-down to get a proper result. Step-down means you reduce the size in steps to allow the limited interpolation range to cover enough pixels for sampling.

This will allow good results also with bi-linear interpolation (it actually behaves much like bi-cubic when doing this) and the overhead is minimal as there are less pixels to sample in each step.

The ideal step is to go to half the resolution in each step until you would set the target size (thanks to Joe Mabel for mentioning this!).

Modified fiddle

Using direct scaling as in original question:

Using step-down as shown below:

In this case you will need to step down in 3 steps:

In step 1 we reduce the image to half by using an off-screen canvas:

// step 1 - create off-screen canvas
var oc   = document.createElement(\'canvas\'),
    octx = oc.getContext(\'2d\');

oc.width  = img.width  * 0.5;
oc.height = img.height * 0.5;

octx.drawImage(img, 0, 0, oc.width, oc.height);

Step 2 reuses the off-screen canvas and draws the image reduced to half again:

// step 2
octx.drawImage(oc, 0, 0, oc.width * 0.5, oc.height * 0.5);

And we draw once more to main canvas, again reduced to half but to the final size:

// step 3
ctx.drawImage(oc, 0, 0, oc.width * 0.5, oc.height * 0.5,
                  0, 0, canvas.width,   canvas.height);

Tip:

You can calculate total number of steps needed, using this formula (it includes the final step to set target size):

steps = Math.ceil(Math.log(sourceWidth / targetWidth) / Math.log(2))

回答2:

I highly recommend pica for such tasks. Its quality is superior to multiple downsizing and is quite speedy at the same time. Here is a demo.

回答3:

    var getBase64Image = function(img, quality) {
    var canvas = document.createElement(\"canvas\");
    canvas.width = img.width;
    canvas.height = img.height;
    var ctx = canvas.getContext(\"2d\");

    //----- origin draw ---
    ctx.drawImage(img, 0, 0, img.width, img.height);

    //------ reduced draw ---
    var canvas2 = document.createElement(\"canvas\");
    canvas2.width = img.width * quality;
    canvas2.height = img.height * quality;
    var ctx2 = canvas2.getContext(\"2d\");
    ctx2.drawImage(canvas, 0, 0, img.width * quality, img.height * quality);

    // -- back from reduced draw ---
    ctx.drawImage(canvas2, 0, 0, img.width, img.height);

    var dataURL = canvas.toDataURL(\"image/png\");
    return dataURL;
    // return dataURL.replace(/^data:image\\/(png|jpg);base64,/, \"\");
}

回答4:

As addition to Ken\'s answer, here another solution to perform the downsampling in halves (so the result looks good using the browser\'s algorithm):

  function resize_image( src, dst, type, quality ) {
     var tmp = new Image(),
         canvas, context, cW, cH;

     type = type || \'image/jpeg\';
     quality = quality || 0.92;

     cW = src.naturalWidth;
     cH = src.naturalHeight;

     tmp.src = src.src;
     tmp.onload = function() {

        canvas = document.createElement( \'canvas\' );

        cW /= 2;
        cH /= 2;

        if ( cW < src.width ) cW = src.width;
        if ( cH < src.height ) cH = src.height;

        canvas.width = cW;
        canvas.height = cH;
        context = canvas.getContext( \'2d\' );
        context.drawImage( tmp, 0, 0, cW, cH );

        dst.src = canvas.toDataURL( type, quality );

        if ( cW <= src.width || cH <= src.height )
           return;

        tmp.src = dst.src;
     }

  }
  // The images sent as parameters can be in the DOM or be image objects
  resize_image( $( \'#original\' )[0], $( \'#smaller\' )[0] );

Credits to this post

回答5:

I created a reusable Angular service to handle high quality resizing of images for anyone who\'s interested: https://gist.github.com/fisch0920/37bac5e741eaec60e983

The service includes Ken\'s step-wise downscaling approach as well as a modified version of the lanczos convolution approach found here.

I included both solutions because they both have their own pros / cons. The lanczos convolution approach is higher quality at the cost of being slower, whereas the step-wise downscaling approach produces reasonably antialiased results and is significantly faster.

Example usage:

angular.module(\'demo\').controller(\'ExampleCtrl\', function (imageService) {
  // EXAMPLE USAGE
  // NOTE: it\'s bad practice to access the DOM inside a controller, 
  // but this is just to show the example usage.

  // resize by lanczos-sinc filter
  imageService.resize($(\'#myimg\')[0], 256, 256)
    .then(function (resizedImage) {
      // do something with resized image
    })

  // resize by stepping down image size in increments of 2x
  imageService.resizeStep($(\'#myimg\')[0], 256, 256)
    .then(function (resizedImage) {
      // do something with resized image
    })
})

回答6:

In case someone else looking for answer still, there is another way which you can use background image instead of drawImage(). You won\'t lose any image quality this way.

JS:

    var canvas=document.getElementById(\"canvas\");
    var ctx=canvas.getContext(\"2d\");
   var url = \"http://openwalls.com/image/17342/colored_lines_on_blue_background_1920x1200.jpg\";

    img=new Image();
    img.onload=function(){

        canvas.style.backgroundImage = \"url(\\\'\" + url + \"\\\')\"

    }
    img.src=\"http://openwalls.com/image/17342/colored_lines_on_blue_background_1920x1200.jpg\";

working demo