MongoDB transactions?

问题:

Playing around with MongoDB and NoRM in .NET.

Thing that confused me - there are no transactions
(can't just tell MongoConnection.Begin/EndTransaction or something like that).

I want to use Unit of work pattern and rollback changes in case something fails.

Is there still a clean way how to enrich my repository with ITransaction?

回答1:

MongoDB doesn't support complex multi-document transactions. If that is something you absolutely need it probably isn't a great fit for you.

In most cases, however, we've found that complex transactions aren't a requirement. All operations in MongoDB are atomic on a single document, and we support nice update modifiers, which make a lot of operations that would need a transaction easy to implement (and fast).

回答2:

That is true that MongoDB does't support transaction out of the box, but you can implement optimistic transactions on your own. They fit fine the unit of work. I wrote an java example and some explanation on a GitHub so you can easily repeat in C#.

回答3:

As of v4.0, MongoDB supports multi-document ACID transactions. Through snapshot isolation, transactions provide a globally consistent view of data, and enforce all-or-nothing execution to maintain data integrity. For more info, see https://www.mongodb.com/transactions

In 4.2, MongoDB will also support sharded transactions.

In this blog post, I also outline our journey to multi-document ACID transactions, in case if you are interested in the history and our reasoning.

回答4:

MongoDB 4.0 will add support for multi-document transactions.

https://www.mongodb.com/transactions

回答5:

Some notes for the record.

While MongoDB does not have transaction support, it supports atomicity on a single document:

MongoDB does have support for atomic operations within a single document. Given the possibilities provided by nested documents, this feature provides support for a large number of use-cases.

Also, the manual entry about "Isolate Sequence of Operations" might be interesting. E.g.:

however, you can isolate a single write operation that affects multiple documents using the isolation operator.

回答6:

You can use instead MongoDb TokuMX.

http://www.tokutek.com/products/tokumx-for-mongodb/

TokuMXTM is an open source, high-performance distribution of MongoDB that has dramatically improved performance and operational efficiency compared to basic MongoDB. TokuMX is a drop-in replacement for MongoDB, and offers 20X performance improvements, 90% reduction in database size, and support for ACID transactions with MVCC.

回答7:

FYI - this has now changed

using (var session = mongoDbContext.MongoDatabase.Client.StartSession())
            {
                var itemAuthRepo = (Repository<ItemAuthorization, ObjectId>)mongoDbContext.ItemAuthorizations;
                var calendarRepo = (Repository<CalendarEvent, ObjectId>)mongoDbContext.Calendars;

                if (itemAuthRepo != null && calendarRepo!=null)
                {
                    session.StartTransaction();

                    try
                    {
                        itemAuthRepo.Collection.InsertOne(session, newItemAuthorization);
                        calendarRepo.Collection.InsertOne(session, cal);
                        session.CommitTransaction();
                    }
                    catch (Exception ex)
                    {
                        session.AbortTransaction();
                        throw;
                    }
                }
                else
                {
                    throw new Exception("IRepository was not casted to Repository");
                }
            }

回答8:

Yes, there are multiple ways to apply Unit of Work pattern for MongoDB depending on the database version.

Until MongoDB 4.0, there was no support for multi-document ACID transactions. Then developers has used "two-phase commit protocol" (single database) and "three-phase commit protocol" (non-blocking on distributed databases) to create their own transaction layer which has provided data consistency but not all-or-nothing execution to maintain data integrity. So that way has taken down the performance.

MongoDB 4.0 has added support for multi-document ACID transactions.

Sources:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Two-phase_commit_protocol

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-phase_commit_protocol

https://www.mongodb.com/transactions