Why does tail probability in apache math drop to z

问题:

Apache Math 3.4 (and 3.3), java 1.8.0_25

import org.apache.commons.math3.distribution.ChiSquaredDistribution;
ChiSquaredDistribution chisq = new ChiSquaredDistribution(23)
System.out.println(1.0 - chisq.cumulativeProbability(130) //  1.1102230246251565E-16
System.out.println(1.0 - chisq.cumulativeProbability(131) //  0.0

Why does Apache Math return 0.0 in the second call? Some stat libraries (Excel, but not R) do return values that are much smaller than 1E-16 for the tail probabilities.

Additional Edit: In the comments below, Robert provides a direct way of calculating chi square tail probabilities using another function from Apache math library (regularizedGammaQ) that does not have this precision problem.

ChiSquaredDistribution Javadoc

回答1:

Note that the smallest value which can be subtracted from 1.0 to yield something less than 1.0 is approximately 1e-16; you can verify this directly. Maybe you should print out chisq.cumulativeProbability(131) itself. I don't know if it's correct but in any case let's not confuse the issue by subtracting it from 1.0.