Difference between pthread and fork on gnu/Linux

问题:

What is the basic difference between a pthread and fork w.r.t. linux in terms of implementation differences and how the scheduling varies (does it vary ?)

I ran strace on two similar programs , one using pthreads and another using fork, both in the end make clone() syscall with different arguments, so I am guessing the two are essentially the same on a linux system but with pthreads being easier to handle in code.

Can someone give a deep explanation?

EDIT : see also a related question

回答1:

In C there are some differences however:

fork()

• Purpose is to create a new process, which becomes the child process of the caller

• Both processes will execute the next instruction following the fork() system call

• Two identical copies of the computer's address space,code, and stack are created one for parent and child.

Thinking of the fork as it was a person; Forking causes a clone of your program (process), that is running the code it copied.

---

pthread_create()

• Purpose is to create a new thread in the program which is given the same process of the caller

• Threads within the same process can communicate using shared memory. (Be careful!)

• The second thread will share data,open files, signal handlers and signal dispositions, current working directory, user and group ID's. The new thread will get its own stack, thread ID, and registers though.

Continuing the analogy; your program (process) grows a second arm when it creates a new thread, connected to the same brain.

回答2:

You should look at the clone manpage.

In particular, it lists all the possible clone modes and how they affect the process/thread, virtual memory space etc...

You say "threads easier to handle in code": that's very debatable. Writing bug-free, deadlock-free multi-thread code can be quite a challenge. Sometimes having two separate processes makes things much simpler.

回答3:

On Linux, the system call clone clones a task, with a configurable level of sharing. fork() calls clone(least sharing) and pthread_create() calls clone(most sharing). forking costs a tiny bit more than pthread_createing because of copying tables and creating COW mappings for memory.