quanteda kwic regex operation

2019-08-09 19:44发布

问题:

Further edit to original question.
Question originated by expectation that regexes would work identically or nearly to "grep" or to some programming language. This below is what I expected and the fact that it did not happen generated my question (using cygwin):

echo "regex unusual operation will deport into a different" > out.txt
grep "will * dep" out.txt
"regex unusual operation will deport into a different"


Originary question
Trying to follow https://github.com/kbenoit/ITAUR/blob/master/README.md
to learn Quanteda after seeing that everybody that uses this package finds it very good.
In demo.R, line 22 I find the line:

kwic(immigCorpus, "deport", window = 3)  

Its output is -

[BNP, 157]        The BNP will | deport | all foreigners convicted  
[BNP, 1946]                . 2. | Deport | all illegal immigrants    
[BNP, 1952] immigrants We shall | deport | all illegal immigrants  
[BNP, 2585]  Criminals We shall | deport | all criminal entrants  

To try/learn the basics I execute

kwic(immigCorpus, "will *depo", window = 3, valuetype = "regex")

expecting to get

[BNP, 157]        The BNP will | deport | all foreigners convicted

but I get:

kwic object with 0 rows

Similar attempts like

kwic(immigCorpus, ".*will *depo.*", window = 3, valuetype = "regex")

Get the same result:

kwic object with 0 rows

Why is that? Tokenization? if so how should I write the regex?

PS Thanks for this great package

回答1:

You are trying to match a phrase with your pattern. By default, the pattern argument is treated as a space separated list of keywords, and the search is performed against this list. So, you may get your expected result using

> kwic(immigCorpus, phrase("will deport"), window = 3)
[BNP, 156:157] - The BNP | will deport | all foreigners convicted

A valuetype = "regex" makes sense if you are using a regex. E.g. to get both shall and will deport use

> kwic(immigCorpus, phrase("(will|shall) deport"), window = 3, valuetype = "regex")

   [BNP, 156:157]             - The BNP | will deport  | all foreigners convicted
 [BNP, 1951:1952] illegal immigrants We | shall deport | all illegal immigrants  
 [BNP, 2584:2585]  Foreign Criminals We | shall deport | all criminal entrants 

See this kwic documentation.



回答2:

The examples from the ITAUR repository are based on an older syntax. What you need is the phrase() wrapper - see ?phrase. You should also probably brush up on the regular expression syntax you are trying to achieve with the *, since it may not be what you want, and since a regular expression cannot start with a "*". (This might help.) The default "glob" valuetype will probably achieve what you want.

library("quanteda")
## Package version: 1.1.4
## Parallel computing: 2 of 8 threads used.
## See https://quanteda.io for tutorials and examples.

kwic(data_char_ukimmig2010, phrase("will deport"))

## [BNP, 156:157] nation.- The BNP | will deport | all foreigners convicted of crimes

kwic(data_char_ukimmig2010, phrase("will .*deport.*"), valuetype = "regex")

## [BNP, 156:157] nation.- The BNP | will deport | all foreigners convicted of crimes