Why does direction of index matter in MongoDB?

问题:

To quote the docs:

When creating an index, the number associated with a key specifies the direction of the index, so it should always be 1 (ascending) or -1 (descending). Direction doesn't matter for single key indexes or for random access retrieval but is important if you are doing sorts or range queries on compound indexes.

However, I see no reason why direction of the index should matter on compound indexes. Can someone please provide a further explanation (or an example)?

回答1:

MongoDB concatenates the compound key in some way and uses it as the key in a BTree.

When finding single items - The order of the nodes in the tree is irrelevant.

If you are returning a range of nodes - The elements close to each other will be down the same branches of the tree. The closer the nodes are in the range the quicker they can be retrieved.

With a single field index - The order won't matter. If they are close together in ascending order they will also be close together in descending order.

When you have a compound key - The order starts to matter.

For example, if the key is A ascending B ascending the index might look something like this:

Row   A B
1     1 1
2     2 6
3     2 7 
4     3 4
5     3 5
6     3 6
7     5 1

A query for A ascending B descending will need to jump around the index out of order to return the rows and will be slower. For example it will return Row 1, 3, 2, 6, 5, 4, 7

A ranged query in the same order as the index will simply return the rows sequentially in the correct order.

Finding a record in a BTree takes O(Log(n)) time. Finding a range of records in order is only OLog(n) + k where k is the number of records to return.

If the records are out of order, the cost could be as high as OLog(n) * k

回答2:

The simple answer that you are looking for is that the direction only matters when you are sorting on two fields.

If you are sorting on {a : 1, b : -1}:

Index {a : 1, b : 1} will be slower than index {a : 1, b : -1}

回答3:

Why indexes

Understand two key points.

1. While an index is better than no index, the correct index is much better than either.
2. MongoDB will only use one index per query, making compound indexes with proper field ordering what you probably want to use.

Indexes aren't free. They take memory, and impose a performance penalty when doing inserts, updates and deletes. Normally the performance hit is negligible (especially compared to gains in read performance), but that doesn't mean that we can't be smart about creating our indexes.

How Indexes

Identifying what group of fields should be indexed together is about understanding the queries that you are running. The order of the fields used to create your index is critical. The good news is that, if you get the order wrong, the index won't be used at all, so it'll be easy to spot with explain.

Why Sorting

Your queries might need Sorting. But sorting can be an expensive operation, so it's important to treat the fields that you are sorting on just like a field that you are querying. So it will be faster if it has index. There is one important difference though, the field that you are sorting must be the last field in your index. The only exception to this rule is if the field is also part of your query, then the must-be-last-rule doesn't apply.

How Sorting

You can specify a sort on all the keys of the index or on a subset; however, the sort keys must be listed in the same order as they appear in the index. For example, an index key pattern { a: 1, b: 1 } can support a sort on { a: 1, b: 1 } but not on { b: 1, a: 1 }.

The sort must specify the same sort direction (i.e. ascending/descending) for all its keys as the index key pattern or specify the reverse sort direction for all its keys as the index key pattern. For example, an index key pattern { a: 1, b: 1 } can support a sort on { a: 1, b: 1 } and { a: -1, b: -1 } but not on { a: -1, b: 1 }.

Suppose there are these indexes:

{ a: 1 }
{ a: 1, b: 1 }
{ a: 1, b: 1, c: 1 }

Example                                                    Index Used
db.data.find().sort( { a: 1 } )                            { a: 1 }
db.data.find().sort( { a: -1 } )                           { a: 1 }
db.data.find().sort( { a: 1, b: 1 } )                      { a: 1, b: 1 }
db.data.find().sort( { a: -1, b: -1 } )                    { a: 1, b: 1 }
db.data.find().sort( { a: 1, b: 1, c: 1 } )                { a: 1, b: 1, c: 1 }
db.data.find( { a: { $gt: 4 } } ).sort( { a: 1, b: 1 } )   { a: 1, b: 1 }